Saturday, October 20, 2012

Guided Meditation: Just Who Do You Think You Are?





LECTIONARY TEXTS: Job 38: 38:1-7, 34-38; Psalm 104; Mark 10: 35-45



REFLECTIONS ON TWO ANCIENT POEMS (Job 38 and Psalm 104)

In response to Job’s pitiable pleas, the thundering voice of God might sound to us like “the great and powerful” Oz addressing Dorothy. I can almost hear the voice of the God-Behind-The-Curtains booming back at Job: “What gives you the right to question your lot in life? ‘Where were you when I laid the foundations of the earth?’ Have you forgotten who I am?”

Maybe Job has.  Maybe we have.  Maybe the writer of Job has forgotten God’s tender compassion.

Or maybe the ancient storyteller is simply describing a very human moment when shallow theology built on fairy tales, really, has left us unprepared for the terrible parts of life.

Maybe you and I come to God expecting a magical wizard who can send us home to a safe place—but terrible times have no simple solutions.  And sometimes we may need to work through still unresolved childhood or young adulthood issues of self-identity and self-acceptance. But we expect God to hand out wisdom, love, and courage as if they are items on a shelf. Instead, back into the scary world God sends us, sniveling like a cowardly lion, feeling as loveless as a tin man, as clueless as a scarecrow. We find ourselves in dark regions far off the beaten yellow brick path to face our lacks and losses, to learn who we are, to give up what we thought mattered.  We’re not in Kansas anymore. Before we can “ease on down the road" into adult faith, before we can make the journey into what Richard Rohr calls “the second half of life,”[i] we may need to think of  God as something other than a cheap magician and approach prayer as something other than a plea to a good wizard.

“Have you forgotten who I am?” God asks me.  Like Job, I, too, often name God as Creator, although I understand the basic scientific principles of evolution.  I still see the primary works of the Spirit as ongoing creation and connection—creation meaning life; connection meaning love. 

Life and love are risky enterprises. If constancy were the prevailing law of the universe, there would be nothing new created, there could be no life. 

So if God is that creative, life-giving force, then there must also be within the life of God some element of randomness and freedom, because both constancy and surprise must exist for life to continue.  Without risk and unpredictability, nothing new could happen. Without the accident of genetic mutations, for instance, humans could not have evolved.  Without chance there can be no change.  The very “laws” of science, it turns out, are not without exceptions.[ii]

I don’t imagine Creator God to be the designer of a fixed road without dangers, but more like the force that imbues us with and lures us on in love and growth.  Although God does not create the pitfalls, God’s creative and loving spirit can redeem those falls, making it possible for us to transcend the terrors and hurts and move into a deeper spiritual realm.  Christianity, at its core, affirms that death leads to rebirth.

Each of us finds a way—sometimes various ways—sometimes mutually conflicting theories—to understand how a loving and powerful God can allow suffering.   The theodicy question is not, for me, entirely resolvable. But the God I serve neither causes suffering nor leave us alone in our pain.  I believe that ordinary or extraordinary healings and rescues occur.  But even when they don’t, the loving and life-giving Spirit keeps moving through the universe through a persistent agenda of life and love.  

Annie Dillard also believes God “does not direct the universe” but “underlies it.” She offers: “The more we wake to holiness, the more of it we give birth to, the more we introduce, expand and multiple it on earth, the more God is ‘on the field’.”  But Dillard has given up on the God who is “that tasking and antiquated figure . . . who sits on the throne of judgment frowning and figuring, and who with the strength of his arm dishes out human fates, in the form of cancer or cash, to 5.9 billion people—to teach, dazzle, rebuke, or try us, one by one, and to punish or reward us, day by day, for our thoughts, words, and deeds.”[iii]  Most of us would agree.  Though our prayer life may suggest otherwise.  

I’m glad the Bible shows God can take our complaints, the stern rebuff from Job’s god notwithstanding.  In fact, the Psalms are full of complaints lifted up to God in faith that God is willing and able to hear all that.  Last Sunday’s Psalm, you’ll remember, began with “My God, my God, why have you forsaken?”  The very words Jesus quoted from the cross.  And words we can imagine coming from Job.

But the lectionary has fittingly paired today’s reading from Job with a praise Psalm that uses the same imagery but a joyful tone in counterpoint to Job’s bitterness.  In our Psalm it is not God who has to assert God’s creative power but the human Psalmist who celebrates it.

So while complaining to God is a legitimate form of prayer, praise is also necessary and equally unstoppable.  We cannot keep from expressing gratitude and awe, even in dire moments, if we gaze upon creation, if we join in the force for love and life. 

I’m not a “Praise the Lord” Christian.  When I hear religious clichés, I imagine folks lifting up the communion cup and toasting their good fortunes, forgetting the chalice holds both joy and sorrow.   

But praise—and its cousin, gratitude, —are important spiritual practices. Praise is an ego-denying practice.  I do need to praise God.  I need to express joy and awe and thanks for this world.  I need to recognize that I am not the center of the universe.  I need to acknowledge The More that is beyond me and yet is sustaining me--because of who I am and because of who God is.  The Eucharistic liturgy says it well:  “It is right to give our thanks and praise.” 

With the words from Job and the Psalmist fresh in our ears, words of complaint and praise, we prepare now to express our petitions and thanks. 

PRAYERS OF THE PEOPLE . . .



[i] Rohr, Richard.  Falling Upward: A Spirituality of the Second Half of Life.  San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 2011.
[ii] These general ideas are influenced by John F. Haught, who sees God as vulnerable love luring us into the future rather than as an intelligent designer. Thus, evolutionary biology is compatible with Christianity. See Haught’s God After Darwin: A Theology of Evolution. Westview Press, 2007.
[iii] Kathryn Huey (http://www.ucc.org/worship/samuel/october-21-2012.html) quotes from "Holy Sparks: A Prayer for the Silent God" in the collection, Best Spiritual Writing 2000.


GUIDED REFLECTION ON THE GOSPEL LESSON: 

Having heard today’s Gospel Reading, I invite you to hear the story again as a guided prayer.  I’ll reread the scripture, pausing at 3 different points to allow for reflection.

1.    James and John, the sons of Zebedee, came forward to [Jesus] and said to him, "Teacher, we want you to do for us whatever we ask of you."

Let this simple stunning demand speak to you about your own prayer life.  Jesus might well have responded to their question with: "Who do you think you are?" or "Who do you think I am?"  He did not, as we'll see in the next verse.  For now, let's reflect on the way we tend to approach God in prayer.  (SILENCE.)  Let’s quietly rest in God’s presence for the next few moments: no agenda, no demands.

SILENCE

2.    And Jesus said to them, "What is it you want me to do for you?" And they said to him, "Grant us to sit, one at your right hand and one at your left, in your glory." But Jesus said to them, "You do not know what you are asking. Are you able to drink the cup that I drink, or be baptized with the baptism that I am baptized with?" They replied, "We are able." Then Jesus said to them, "The cup that I drink you will drink; and with the baptism with which I am baptized, you will be baptized; but to sit at my right hand or at my left is not mine to grant, but it is for those for whom it has been prepared."

Reflect now on what you really ask of God.  Is it possible we don’t know what we are asking?  In the Bible the cup and baptism can mean both blessing and hardship.  With blessing there is challenge.  Are we willing to accept both?

SILENCE


3.    When the [other] ten [disciples] heard this, they began to be angry with James and John. So Jesus called them and said to them, "You know that among the Gentiles those whom they recognize as their rulers lord it over them, and their great ones are tyrants over them. But it is not so among you; but whoever wishes to become great among you must be your servant, and whoever wishes to be first among you must be slave of all. For the Son of Man came not to be served but to serve, and to give his life a ransom for many."

Once again Jesus reverses the world’s ways and says that to be great we must serve.  If it is comfortable for you to do so, you might pull down the kneeler in front of you to get into that traditional prayer posture, the posture of a servant.  With bowed head or bent knee, reflect on Jesus’s way of leading by serving.  How might we at Open Table do a better job of enacting that visionary and focused yet humbly serving model of leadership?   (silence) How can we as individuals measure our lives by Jesus’s standard of greatness? Consider how we as individuals sometimes, for instance, expect others to do things to accommodate our preferences, to ‘serve’ us?  Isilence) Now think about people you might be serving.  How might you as a family member, as a neighbor, as a responsible voter consider “the least” and serve their interests in the name of Jesus?

SILENCE




Sunday, October 14, 2012

A Broadly Narrow Way



 Text: Mark 10: 17-31

A slightly bawdy and belittling song from the musical South Pacific begins this way:

My doll is as dainty as a sparrow,
Her figure is somethin' to applaud.
Where she's narrow she's as narrow as an arrow,
And she's broad where a broad should be broad.

I hope the tune of "Honey Bun" will not be looping through your brain during the rest of the sermon.  What's been replaying in my brain this week is the question of where should we be broad--and where narrow.  I have been wondering, thanks to today's Gospel reading, about the places where the Jesus Way is narrow and where it is broad. Some scriptures emphasize Jesus's broad invitation to all people to follow him along an expansive, limitless journey: Samaritans, poor people, children, all.  Other scriptures suggest we follow Jesus on a path that is as “narrow as an arrow”--to use Oscar and Hammerstein's simile--or, to use Jesus's phrase, we approach the realm of God through an opening as narrow as "the eye of a needle.”  

If we had to choose between those two adjectives to describe our congregation, we would probably choose broad over narrow.  We at Open Table tend to think of ourselves as broadminded, meaning we think we have made room in our minds for some new ideas that we did not inherit from our families or receive unquestioningly from the majority culture. Some of these departures from the ideological and theological "straight and narrow" have been liberating and healing.  But today's Gospel reading reminds me that Jesus taught that God's way is both inclusive and in some sense restrictive. 

Today's Gospel story focuses on Jesus's warning to a good man that the path to God is too narrow to travel with riches in tow.  To keep moving toward God, this man needed to give all his possessions to the poor, according to Jesus.  And the good man, unwilling to give up such wealth, went away very sad.  For him, the journey with Jesus was too rigorous, too narrow.  Like this good man, we can get only so far along the Jesus Way with our encumbrances.

There are times when you and I need to reaffirm the breadth of God's love, captured so well in the words of a favorite hymn:
There's a wideness in God's mercy, like the wideness of the sea.   
There's a kindness in God's justice that is more than liberty.
For the love of God is broader than the measure of our mind.
And the love of the Eternal is most wonderfully kind.

A church like ours knows how to sing those broad words.

But today we are mining a particular Gospel story.  So I want challenge you, as I challenge myself, to be broadminded enough to consider the possibility that we might be making the Gospel into a broader way than Jesus intended.  For today, let’s imagine Jesus’s Way as a narrow spiritual path.

One way progressive Christians can make Jesus's way too broad is by accepting the false dichotomy that a person or society either conforms to an ethic based on strict authoritarianism or gives in to runaway moral relativism. Because progressives doubt that Christian ethics can be based simply and solely on literal interpretations of biblical commandments and edicts from religious leaders, we must take extra care not to sound as if we're endorsing an "anything goes" ethic of self-indulgent individualism.  Wary of being judgmental, we sometimes fail to articulate our own values and teach them to our children.  We might, for instance, be so committed to affirming the wide range of healthy human sexual expressions that we fail to develop guidelines for healthy sexuality.  It's easy to come up with a list of dos and don'ts.  It's hard to create processes to determine what is ethical in a rapidly changing culture.  Living in the freedom of Christ is not a license to behave however we wish. The Jesus Way of love is not so broad that it includes harmful behavior. Let's be guided by an ethic of love and integrity that is narrow enough to be truly loving and just.

Our emphasis on the breadth of the Gospel also has the potential to weaken our personal commitment to the Way of Jesus. Sometimes people enter congregations like ours after hurtful experiences in past churches.  They are gun shy, which is to say they are Bible shy and Jesus shy, since both the Bible and Jesus have been aimed at them.  So we try to make it easy to participate here to whatever degree feels comfortable.  We even have joked about people being embarrassed to tell their friends they are attending a church so we allow them to be “in the closet"--the “Christian closet."  But even the majority of us who are “out” Christians certainly don’t want to shove our religion down someone’s throat.

Eventually, of course, many of us find we can’t help sharing in natural conversations about our church family, about ways we are being shaped here, about the deepening of our spiritual lives that comes from following Jesus’s generous but hard way.  We won’t let others’ pushy proselytizing prevent us from sharing about a way that has been strengthening for us.

Jesus is said to have warned, "Not everyone who says to me, 'Lord, Lord' will enter the kingdom" (Matt. 7:21).  To me that was not a threat of hell but a simple statement of fact that not everyone who says they are a follower of the Jesus Way is actually committed to that difficult but healing way.  We at Open Table have opened up membership to all who wish to follow in Jesus's ways of love, spiritual and social transformation, radical hospitality, grace-filled inclusion, and joyful encounters with the Holy.  There is not, in other words, a doctrinal test for membership.  Our members do not have to attest to any particular beliefs.  We can mean different things when we talk about following in the way of Jesus.

If that seems a lax standard for membership, ask yourself which is easier: to sign off on certain statements about Jesus that no one can fully fathom and parrot a creed regularly or to try earnestly to align one's life with Jesus’s life and teachings as we try to love God and love neighbor as we love ourselves? Some might see us creating too broad a category for legitimate church membership. I believe ours is a more exacting commitment. 

But it’s possible for us to forget our commitments. For instance, we, on the congregational level, can let a handful of congregational leaders do most of the work.  We can fail to hold all members responsible for regular and even sacrificial contributions of time and skills and financial resources. Because some of us have been burned out by churchy demands in the past or are already committed to good work elsewhere, we can be afraid to ask too much of our members and participants. Which means we fail to call out the giftedness of everyone.  Which means we fail to flourish as fully as we might.

Clarence Jordan, who helped Millard Fuller found Habitat for Humanity, told about meeting a country preacher in the Deep South in the 1960s who was leading a relatively large and amazingly integrated congregation of black and white and rich and poor people.[i]  When asked how the church had achieved such a beautiful mixture of people, the preacher explained that on his first Sunday as pastor he preached from the book of Galatians, reading "For as many of you as have been baptized into Jesus, there are no longer Jews or Greeks, slaves or free, males or females, because you are one in Jesus."  He closed the Bible and declared, "If you is one with Jesus, you is one with all kind of folks.  And if you aint, well, you aint." 

Jordan asked what happened after that. "Well," the preacher said, "the deacons took me into the back room and told me they didn't want to hear that kind of preaching no more." 

The preacher persisted and soon the deacons left the church.

"Then what happened?" asked Jordan. 

"Well," said the country preacher, "I preached that church down to four people.  Not long after that, it started growing.  And it grew.  And I found out that revival sometimes don't mean bringin' people in but gettin' people out that don't dare to love Jesus."

My aim is certainly not to preach our numbers down!  But that country preacher was right about this: Jesus's way is too narrow to contain prejudice or meanness or ego or privilege.  We cheapen the way of Jesus when we downplay the cost of followship.

Which leads me to a final way we might make the Jesus way too broad.  I believe we can inadvertently, in the name of freedom of thought, permit theological laziness. I ask that we continue to honor wide-ranging views here, but let’s also expect theological rigor of one another. Not all theological positions can be equally valid. Not all claims about God or the way of Jesus can be equally true.  We certainly appreciate ambiguity and paradox. We admit the Bible itself speaks variously on topics so Christian theologies bump up against one another.  So let’s not settle for flimsy answers—even if it means our deepest questions are never completely answered.

For instance, when we wonder about the reasons for human suffering, a predominant biblical theme expressed in today's Psalm and the Hebrew Bible reading, we are challenged to structure a framework to hold our tough questions. We realize that the belief in a God who orders or allows every action in this universe collides with the idea that humans have choice (free will) as well as the belief that God's ways are always loving. Even if we were to say that God chastens us for a time so that suffering can serve some ultimate good, we would still have to confront a God who causes short- term pain--which gives us a God who is cruel some of the time. We, just like the Psalmist and like Job, might feel as if God is causing or allowing pain or injustice in our life or in the world.  That's how it feels.  And we, like Job and the Psalmist, might pray to God to relent.  But if we believe in a loving God, then we have logical limits on any understanding that God is the author of suffering. So our theologizing gets complicated. We all have theological positions that shape us. As a congregation that regularly tries to do theological reflection together, let’s give space for diverse theologies even as we cultivate both disciplined spirits and disciplined minds. 

But staying in our heads is another danger for broadminded Progressives.  We bring to the public sphere an ability to expose root causes rather than simply apply band aid solutions to social problems, and we are pretty good at advocating and educating and creating new solutions, but we are prone to talking about issues rather than doing something.  We read and study and debate but sometimes fail to get around to doing. We are challenged to narrow the possible courses of action and then to pour our energies into that narrow, well-focused plan.

Likewise, we want to remain clear about Open Table’s mission and identity.  We can welcome everyone without pretending to the best place or path for everyone.  Our language and liturgy and symbols can stretch and accommodate—but not infinitely. We cannot be all things to all people. People may visit us and find we're not the best fit for them.  And we should be happy they figured that out.  People may be active with us for some time and then realize the path they are on no longer coincides with the path we are traveling.  And we can bless them as they make the next part of their journey with another group of sojourners.  We have the capacity to bless folks in their comings ad going with grateful hearts.

Here is our challenge, dear friends: to be broad in our welcome and our love; to be narrow in our focus, in our theological rigor, in our commitment, and in our ethical conduct.

PRAYER: Lead us, Jesus, in your way.  Where it broadens, expand our hearts.  Where it narrows, let us shed what is not essential.  Where it darkens, let us see by your light.  Amen


[i] http://day1.org/1473-the_peril_and_the_promise_of_being_met_by_jesus  Will Willimon tells this story in “The Peril and the Promise of of Being met By Jesus”

Saturday, October 6, 2012

Neighbors in Need



WORLD COMMUNION SUNDAY

Text: Luke 10: 25-37

The questions were proceeding methodically.  The opponent had just asked Jesus to comment on the two most important commandments.  In that critical audience, it was a topic with as many minefields as today's topic of the national debt.

But Jesus affirmed his antagonist’s point—that love of God and love of neighbor were at the heart of the law.  

Hoping to highlight their differences and Jesus’s unorthodoxy, the lawyer probed further, perhaps ready with a well-rehearsed zinger in response. "Just how do you define 'neighbor'?" he pressed.

Never one for the oppositional thinking that debater and lawyers prefer, Jesus told a story instead, a risky rhetorical move aimed both at exploding their neat categories and finding common ground. The audience might have been hoping to hear a plan to reduce the requirements of the law of love, to allow them to love less, but here was Jesus, expanding the list of those covered under that law. 

Jesus began:  "A man was robbed and beaten and left for dead on a wilderness road.  A priest came upon him but avoided getting involved.  Another religious functionary also passed him by.  But a Samaritan--a man from a despised region and religion--went out of his way to rescue and care for the injured victim."

Then Jesus did the unthinkable: he turned the question back upon the interviewer. 

"In this story, whom do YOU think acts as a neighbor?" 

Like that, Jesus invested all his listeners with the moral responsibility to enter into that story themselves.

The opponent answered for all of them: "The one who showed mercy behaved as a neighbor."  By doing so he conceded Jesus's point.

Polls show Jesus won the debate.

What most of us hear in this familiar story is Jesus's insistence that we expand our sense of who is our neighbor in order to love and care even for people who are different from us.  "Love your neighbor," we hear Jesus saying to us, "and be especially sure you are, like the 'good Samaritan,' caring for those who are very different from you." We get that point.  At least on an intellectual level.

But what we sometimes miss in this story is not just our obligation to care for those who are very different from us--but also the realization that even the despised have something to offer us.  From the perspective of Jesus's listeners, the foreign Samaritan in the story is not the person needing care but the person who might be able to offer care.

Think about it. Jesus could have told the story differently if his sole point were to evoke love for those on the margins.  He might have recast the story so that the despised Samaritan was the victim rather than the hero.  Here's how that would have sounded:

A Samaritan was robbed and beaten and left for dead on a wilderness road.  First one and then another person passed him by, unwilling to stop and help.  At last came a Jewish priest--a man despised by the Samaritan and a man who'd been taught to hate him back.  But this priest put aside his obligations at the Temple, his religious purity codes, and his prejudice.  At great risk and personal expense, the Jewish priest took responsibility for the care of the injured Samaritan. Whom do YOU think acts like a neighbor in this story? 

Such a telling would have made very clear that the Samaritan in need--and others we tend to ignore--should receive our help. If Jesus had made the Samaritan the victim and the priest the helper, Jesus might have driven home the point that his Jewish audience needed to care for the foreigners whom their culture despised. 

But Jesus used the Samaritan as HERO to make two points: that we should help the marginalized--yes--but also to open up another possibility we rarely hear in this story.  The Good Samaritan shows us that the ones we are quick to disregard are actually the ones who might save us.

The folks on the fringes--like Jesus himself--are our saviors.

I wonder if you can recall some time when you were ostensibly in the role of rescuer, helper, teacher, guide or leader--yet you came away from that experience feeling that you had been the one who was saved, helped, taught, guided or led.  I can.  When I have visited you in the hospital and have come away with a deeper sense of the Holy.  When I have sacrificed precious time to read to a child and have had my spirits lifted.  When I have offered compassionate listening to someone struggling to come out of the closet, and I have clearly heard the voice of God in that encounter.  When I have lost track of time in some project for another and have experienced the blessing of self-forgetting.  The ones we go to save often become our saviors.

When we give money to the Neighbors in Need offering to support UCC efforts for justice in the world, we help fund projects that aid others through new literacy programs and food banks and environmental projects--but we are also creating opportunities for those sister congregations to be "saved" by the folks they are serving.

When we serve others in our community--through Family Promise, for example--we are also being saved in the process.

Saved from what?  you might ask.  Because it's probably clear from the context that I'm not using the word saved in the way television evangelists preaching hellfire mean saved.

I would say we are saved from whatever it is that is killing our spirits.  That might be self-centeredness.  Greed.  Isolation.  Fear.  Self-deception.  Ego.  The enslaving and dispiriting demons are many.  But we are saved, by God’s grace, by living a life in the way that Jesus demonstrated, by being followers of The Way. It is the way that offers eternal life.

If you think I’ve strayed a long way from the story by now, look back at how this Gospel reading began.  The lawyer began interrogating Jesus by asking what was required for “eternal life.”

Jesus led the lawyer to a conclusion that love of God and neighbor and self were the key.  The story of the Good Samaritan is really about the way to eternal life.

Our love of neighbors--neighbors barbequing across the wooden fences of our quiet subdivisions and neighbors praying at the mosques in Baghdad--are saving us for the "eternal life" Jesus offers. 

Some teach that eternal life begins after we die and on top of fluffy clouds behind golden gates.  Others say—more persuasively, in my opinion—that eternal life is always right here and now.  Otherwise, it’s not eternal.  Eternity has no beginning nor end, no past nor future.  Implicit in Jesus’s response to the learned lawyer is this key to eternity:  If you both give and receive care to those who are different from you, you develop within you a divine compassion that unites you to the One of all times and places.  National boundaries fall away when you can love with God’s love.  Past and future lose their distinctions.  When love is the only commandment . . .when another’s welfare is as important to me as my own. . . when worries about old failings or future security evaporate. . . then we are living a unbounded, eternal (what the Gospel of John calls "abundant") life, a life in union with Eternal God.  We have entered eternity.  Selfless love of neighbor--giving and receiving from the one we might otherwise despise--is a portal through which we experience Divine love.  So said Jesus.

Richard Rohr has observed (in The Eternal Now) that the only time Jesus talks about the future is when he said not to worry about it.  Jesus, according to Rohr, is not talking about some future event when he talks about eternal life.  Nor does Jesus talk about the past except to say the past is forgiven.  Let go of who you think you are and live now, say Rohr, interpreting Jesus.  Jesus calls us to live in the now.  Ironically, we have made Jesus into a punisher of our past and a gatekeeper to our future.

On this World Communion Sunday we have the joy of imagining all those human-made boundaries falling away at Christ’s Open Table.  It is a table that accommodates the whole world—including all people from all times.  It is set with bread that is the body of Christ, and as we internalize that body, we ourselves become part of that picture of the unitive way of God.  It is a meal at which Christ is both the host—and the guest—and the broken bread that feeds us.  We have to give up literal and dualistic thinking to enter this kind of unboundaried space and see Jesus as the one rejected and the one celebrated—the one who walked this earth long ago and the very same one who accompanies us on the way in this moment of time. 

When we gather around the Open Table, we recall the ministry of Jesus, the one who reached out to those on the margins.  We recall the death of Jesus, whose spirit lives on in ways that confound the lawyers and debaters.  When we share the communion bread, we are partaking of his life.  And we are identifying with the despised one who saves us. 

In fact, the deepest expressions of the love that God calls out in us are often experienced between people who had seemed to have no affinity. 

Thanks be to God for neighbors we might otherwise scorn—but who call to us across our differences with healing and help.  May we offer saving love to neighbors, far and near.  May we let them save us.  In the name of Jesus, neighbor to all.   Amen

Sunday, September 23, 2012

When God is a Child: Children as Guide and Goal


Text: Mark 9: 30-37


"The Peaceable Kingdom" by Paul Mariani*


There can be something scary about all the energy, unpredictability, forthrightness, and frankness packed into little beings who look so much like us but don't know athe social codes that buffer us from awkward encounters.  So we are uneasy if the child we greet ducks her head and refuses to reply.  Or if the baby placed in our arms starts wailing and can't be consoled.  We don't know what to say if a toddler asks, "Why is your nose so big?"  Which is exactly why we need children in our all-too settled and certain lives.  Many of the world's religions teach that a little child will lead us, that a divine child will save us.  But it is not sweet innocence that makes children such good emissaries of the Holy. It's their ability to strip away pretense and privilege.  It's the fact that they are the iconic "least of these" Jesus said are the best ambassadors of God's realm.

We tend to romanticize childhood but ignore children.  We imagine Jesus gathering around him children who were as well-behaved, well-scrubbed, and well-dressed as the cast of the Cosby Show--because those little ones are easy to welcome: the precocious ones who say amusing things . . . the precious ones who warm our hearts.

But real children sometimes, if we're honest, make us uncomfortable.  They are unpredictable. They are often troubled.  They make so much noise and have so many needs.

Paul Mariani's poem--and Mark's Gospel--will not let us sentimentalize children.  Like the speaker of the poem who nervously faces eighteen kindergartners, Jesus's disciples don't know what to do with the little ankle biters who follow in his wake.  In the next chapter of Mark we will read that the disciples try to block the children's access to Jesus.  Shooing away the children  after Jesus had just told the to welcome them shows how persistent is human resistance to welcome the least welcome.

On this hard truth hangs the doctrine of incarnation: God comes to us as a child.  We tend to pull out this doctrine once a year with the Christmas ornaments. But God comes not only as the peasant baby born in ancient Bethlehem.  God is the child on the streets of modern day Calcutta or Khartoum.  Or Mobile.  And though we think our culture is both child-centered and God-fearing, 22% of children in the U.S. live below the poverty line (according to the 2010 US Census) through no fault of their own.  More sobering still is the statistic that 38.2% of African American children live in poverty, numbers suggesting we care less about these Christ-bearers and the ways of God than we profess.  In our culture we turn a blind eye to the most vulnerable as we overindulge the children of privilege.  Yet even children living in physical comfort can be impoverished in terms of affection and care and guidance.

Perhaps even we at Open Table, so proud of the beautiful and brilliant children and young people in our midst, might improve our welcome.  I wonder if sometimes we assume that a gentle smile is someone else's job.  Or if we go to the other extreme and make too much of a young person who might dislike too much scrutiny? Do our children smell the awkwardness or impatience on us?  Do we sometimes forget that children are not here to amuse us but  connect us to the divine?  We have an obligation to teach them about the life of faith, but they have much to teach us. Jesus said when you welcome them, you are ushering me into your midst.  When you listen to a child, you are hearing the voice of God.

And if that claim sounds strange to our ears, it was even more shocking--probably even offensive--to most 1st Century citizens, who very intentionally marginalized children.

However, children are quite literally at the center of Mark's Gospel account of a counter-cultural Jesus.  For the last 3 Sundays I detoured from the lectionary's progress through Mark in order to preach from James, but as we return to Mark's Gospel, let's place today's scripture in the context of the Mark's entire 9th chapter, which is almost smack dab in the middle of that brief Gospel and certainly at its thematic center.

Chapter 9 begins with the indisputable climax of Jesus's ministry, the story of his transfiguration atop a high mountain. Having just been so exalted by God, Jesus immediately warns the disciples that his ignoble death is near.  Having just been elevated, his next miracle is to heal an epileptic child in the most detailed healing story of Mark's gospel (Mark 9:17-30): from the pinnacle of glory to the service of the lowly.  Then, as Jesus and followers pass through Galilee, he again tells the disciples that he will be killed--and will rise on the third day. Their insensitive response to Jesus' sense of his imminent death? They begin arguing about who among them is the greatest--perhaps to determine who would become his successor.  As the disciples jockey for power, Jesus spies the most powerless figure nearby, a little child, and brings him silently into the middle of the circle.  He holds the child as he explains that the way we treat little ones (like the child in his arms) is the way we treat him--and the way we treat him is the way we will experience God.  The child leads us Godward.

An advent song by Brian Wren is titled "When God is a Child" and the refrain says this:

When God is a child, there's joy in our song.
The last shall be first and the weak shall be strong.
And none shall be afraid.

At a former church we often sang this hymn during Advent, a different verse each week, as a different child each week would light the appropriate candle in the Advent wreath.  One Advent the child lighting the wreath sang part of the song as a solo each week.   The congregation sang together the verse and refrain--until the last line.  On the final line, all other voices dropped out and the child sang, alone, "And none shall be afraid."  What a powerful image of the weak being strong, of the power of vulnerability.

As we see in Mark's Gospel, Jesus welcomed the children, not because they were cute, but because they were considered the least, the most vulnerable, and they were the key to this great reversal of priorities at the heart of his teachings.  When God is a child, we "get" this reversal.  Then God's realm, if momentarily, holds sway.

Our children--the children of the world and the children right here at Open Table--are not only our guides to God but also our very goal.  Again, Jesus welcomed the children because they were living reminders of our goal.  Not by virtue  of their adorableness.  But because a life of stripped-down vulnerability relies on trust. That is my heart's goal.

Have you ever seen the movie "The Curious Case of Benjamin Button"?  Brad Pitt plays the title role as a man born with the body of a very old man who gradually grows younger and younger with each passing year until, after more than 80 years of life, he returns to infancy.  And dies.  His life culminates in a new born state.  And that may be what Jesus was recommending to Niccodemus about being born again.  Our goal in life is not to acquire and attain and achieve more and more but to become like a child, bare and vulnerable and dependent totally on God.

Author Bruno Scholz put it this way: "If it were possible to reverse development, to attain the state of childhood again, to have its abundance and limitlessness once more, that 'age of genius,' those 'messianic times' promised and sworn to us by all mythologies would come to pass. My ideal goal is to 'mature into childhood'."

Robin Maas asks this: "How is it, then, that such a fundamental aspect of revelation should continue so consistently ignored, sentimentalized, suppressed?  Why do we steadfastly resist the obvious implications of Jesus' teachings on childhood and even more, his own childhood, as a sign not of the beginning of our spiritual quest but, in a very real sense, as its consummation?"

Why indeed?  Because it is hard to pursue a goal that is about not pursuing a goal.  The spiritual goal is paradoxically achieved by giving up, by "falling upward" as Richard Rohr suggests in the book we'll study in October.

Working hard and being responsible and taking on challenges is healthy and necessary.  We're talking here about a spiritual process that totally redirects our lives.  We're talking about receiving love as trustingly as a baby nurses at the breast of his mother.

The child is both guide and goal.  And children embody the world's hope.  Every time a child enters the world--a child who is like none other--there is fresh hope for the just and peaceful reign of God. Our planet would not be so imperiled if we had been listening to the future generations not yet born but for whom we are responsible.  We need to be led by the child of hope.

Hear the prophet Isaiah:  "For unto us a child is born . . .  and her name shall be called Wonderful Counselor, the Mighty God, the Everlasting Mother, the Princess of Peace."

Whether we have literally birthed children or not, each of us has the responsibility to give birth to hope. Each of us must nurture new life on this planet.  We are charged to be both parent and child, generating hope and embodying hope, listening to children to hear God directing us.  And each of us lives on faith that God is already upholding us. There is a new way, there are novel thoughts, there are fresh possibilities.  There is hope.  When there are children.  Because God is a child.

PRAYER.  Young God, we would follow your voice that we often hear best from those this world considers the least.  Thy kingdom come, we pray. Thy will be done so that to be first we must be last and the servant of all.