Sunday, January 6, 2013

They Returned Home. By a Different Road.

Sermon text: Matthew 2: 1-12




They went home.  By another road.

After brilliance broke into their awareness . . . after that illumination first unsettled and then drew them toward a deeper reality . . . after they saw by that light something fragile and ordinary and impotent and holy . . .  after they at last recognized what kind of power kills and what kind of power saves . . . the Wise Ones returned home.  But by a different road. 

Here’s today’s sermon in a nutshell: The wise ones went home after all their searching.  But they took a different road.

Richard Rohr might categorize the story of the Wise Ones as an archetypal myth about the second stage of life.  After detours and dangers, their journey comes full circle with a homecoming like that of the Greek hero Odysseus.  Matthew’s Magi and Homer’s Odysseus suggest that spiritual maturation requires us to do two things: to return to our spiritual home but to return by a different and often difficult road.  After all the wandering, seeking, searching, and striving we've done in the "first half of life,”[i] we (gradually or abruptly) begin to point homeward, changed. Yet we return by way of a different path.

Poet T. S. Eliot could be describing Odysseus or the wise men or you when he says that "the end of all our exploring / will be to arrive where we started for the first time."
Jesus scholar Marcus Borg is describing the path to Christian maturity when he invites us to “meet Jesus again . . . for the first time.”

Have you experienced that sort of paradoxical epiphany? We at Open Table are hoping to make a way for folks to return to a home in God—but by a different route.  Some say their involvement in Open Table has led them to take another look at Jesus after maybe many years of indifference or even dislike—and that second look has revealed a familiar and yet totally new Jesus. 

Of course, in today's story of epiphany, the infant Jesus and his mother are barely mentioned, and father Joseph not at all.  The drama focuses on the murderous King Herod, on some (at best) neutral religious leaders in Jerusalem, and on some godly foreigners who probably came from what is present day Iraq or Iran. God was revealed to these honest seekers from another culture; God was found by these wise ones in an unexpected place wearing an unexpected face.  The religious leaders who should have known about and protected the Christ child abdicated their leadership role, being so entwined, as they were, with the political authorities, so committed to maintaining institutions and customs, so suspicious of those who are different, so protective of their own power.  Instead, it was up to those with a different way of seeing the world—strangers from afar—to recognize God's activity and then act wisely enough to escape being used for harm.

The spiritual journey many of us find ourselves on is not so different from that of the wise men. A gradual or sudden illumination pierced through the fog of what we thought was true and then set us searching.  We wandered, some of us, for years.  We may have left religious life entirely or tried a range of spiritual practices and investigated a variety of religious traditions.  Or we may have sat politely in a pew somewhere as a silent heretic, our wanderings being interior and secret. But at some point we caught a glimpse of the Really Real, or at least the possibility of something that is of ultimate worth that might save us and save our world, and we felt a longing to kneel to and serve that goodness in the world. We don’t understand this inner shift any more than the Magi did.  But like them, we seem to be heading back to a spiritual awareness that is connected to our past and yet is also a new and deeper place.  This spiritual state just might be our truest home.  But to get there we must go by a route different than the one we used years ago.

Let’s spend a moment considering what home might mean for those of us on a spiritual quest.  Then we’ll consider what it might mean for us to journey home by a different road.

I love Robert Penn Warren’s definition of home as “not a place” but a “state of spirit . . . of mind . . .  a proper relation to the world.”  What happens if we think of God not as a father or mother, but as home itself, not as a being with whom we have relationship but as the spiritual state whereby we are nurtured and become related to one another?  What if, then, our spiritual goal is to become at home in the world and within our own spirits and with one another?   

God—as our home—is our starting place and that place to which we long to return. If life is a circle rather than a line, then God, who can be conceived of as our home, is both our origin and goal. I am not talking about God as existing in some place.  I’m talking about God as that figurative place. I am not imagining God as a home for me at some distant point in time but rather as my home I experience now. If God is a home to enter only after we die, then we live estranged lives here.  And if God, by the way, is a home that shelters only certain family members, then God is mean and small. If God is home for me, then God is a home here and now and for all. God as home is not a new image. The hymn, “O God Our Help in Ages Past” concludes by affirming God as “our eternal home.” Mystics have imaged God as home.  Scriptures name God as our “refuge” and “hiding place” and “rock” and “shelter.” Unfortunately, the image that came to dominate our thinking to such an extent that it becomes idolatry is the image of God as father.

Thinking about God as my home shapes my theology; feeling God as my home shapes my prayers.  If I meditate on God as home, I’m less likely to childishly present Father God with a list of requests and am more likely to settle into a spirit of calm and compassion that enables me to see the rest of the world embraced within this same home. Such prayer is about changing me rather than changing God.  I invite you to try prayer as a discipline of very intentionally but simply making yourself at home in the world.  Then tell me if it changes you.

Understanding God as home can alter not only our prayers but also our ethics and actions.  If God is my most ultimate “home,” then my spiritual practices must lead to relatedness with others who live within this home that God IS.  To be specific, if my spirituality is based on the sense that my god is, in some sense, my ultimate home and if my goal in life is to be at home, then I may also try harder to honor the planet that is our physical home and the creatures that share this home with me. Perhaps those who are “at home in the world” are those who can best work for peace and protect our planet. As a church, we find ourselves engaged in many important causes, but I wonder if the most basic issues of justice are those which foster just and peaceful human relationships and those which ensure a healthier environment for all creatures because we care about our mutual home.

Yet these also happen to be, for me at least, the most challenging personal commitments. It’s hard for me to live a life of peace.  It’s hard for me to monitor all the ways my daily habits affect the natural environment. But the God who holds the universe in a communal embrace is calling me to return home, which, if God is Home, is another way of talking about the old concept of conversion. I need to be converted, to turn away from actions that harm my home, to return to God, to our “home.”

If we return to God, like the Prodigal son who returns home from a life of disconnection and dissolution, we, too, can be reintegrated into a deep sense of being at home in the world and comfortable in our own skin.  That is spiritual maturity.

But we can go home again only via a different road.  My theology today is very different than it was 30 years ago. Yours has probably evolved, too.  I thank God for new paths I’ve tried, strange characters I’ve met. On most days I can even thank God for heartaches endured.  Like the wise men, we dare not retrace our steps but return home by a different way. 

Nearly eight years ago I literally returned home—having left Mobile in 1974 to go off to college and eventually to follow career paths to live in Georgia, then Texas, then Tennessee, and then Ohio.  The thought of returning home was both a welcome and worrisome prospect.  I was newly ordained and eager for my first full-time ministerial role, but my chances of finding a congregation to serve plummeted when George and I decided he should accept a position at Spring Hill College.  COULD I return home if I’d changed so much theologically, politically, spiritually?  Only by a different road.  I returned home, for instance, after having made deep and lasting friendships with LGBT folks, having heard their stories, having marched in Pride parades, having served Open and Affirming churches. I could not return to Mobile and just pretend I had not been, in some sense, converted along the way.  My real home in God had to include all the folks I’d encountered, regardless of whether my geographical home was willing to include those people and ideas. 

On Friday, as Jan and Sondra and I were driving downtown to participate in the We Do campaign for marriage equality, Jan asked me if, when I was growing up in Mobile, I’d have imagined I’d be participating in such an event.  I answered that I could not have even imagined such an event taking place—much less my role in it—not even when I was well into adulthood.  Indeed, I was well into adulthood before I could imagine a woman becoming a pastor.  And my spiritual conversion relative to the topic of human sexuality happened over many years and thanks, mainly, to relationships with gay and lesbian friends.  It’s my own slow but steady conversion that gives me hope that others can come to recognize their prejudices and trust that God, like a loving home, holds us all together equally, safely, supportively.  I’ve come home by a different way.  It’s the only way we ever really return to our truest home that some call God.  It’s the differences the Wise Ones encounter on the road home that save us and help us save the ones today’s Herods would harm. 

Through the Gospels we come to understand that the infant Jesus would also journey home.  By a different way.  The call upon my life is to follow in that way.  The mission of Open Table is to follow Jesus.  Who taught us a different way.

In the musical Les Miserable, Jean Valjean sings a final prayer as he is dying. Audiences probably hear him asking God to bring him to a home that is heaven. But perhaps you can hear me pray this prayer as one fully engaged in life who is longing to be brought into an experience of God as our truest home. I pray this for us all:

God on high,
Hear my prayer
In my need

You have always been there

Where you are
Let me be
Take me now
Take me there
Bring me home
Bring me home. 

Amen


[i] See Richard Rohr’s Falling Upward: A Spirituality for the Two Halves of Life.

Monday, December 31, 2012

A love letter and thank you note to Open Table

an early gathering of Open Table

Friends,  

I thank Linda T. for being willing to facilitate tonight’s Festive Fifth Sunday gathering and lead you in sharing stories.  Even missing one gathering time with you means I’ll miss something important—an insight someone shares, a story that helps us understand one another better, a joke that loses some of its humor when it’s retold in another setting, the light of your dear faces.  I will miss being with you tonight, but I am thankful for a few days to be with my family.  

I told a somewhat silly story in my sermon last week.  Your stories for tonight might be funny or tender or both. Sharing stories and a meal, which you'll do tonight, are two of the most powerful of spiritual disciplines in all cultures—and are at the root of Christianity’s central ritual. Holy Communion is all about retelling the story of Jesus and recommitting to his ways of loving union through a common meal.  A faith community called Open Table knows well the hows and whys of this communal practice. 

According to the liturgical calendar, this is the sixth day of Christmas, so although the larger culture thinks Christmas is over, the Church continues celebrating the coming of God in the very unexpected form of a human child.  Although the “after Christmas sales” have started, we’re still mining the story of the incarnation, the “enfleshment” of the sacred.  We recall that the incarnation is a story that shows God being revealed to us in ordinary physicality, God coming to us as vulnerable love.   

Next Sunday I’ll share with you some themes we’ll explore in the new year.  But our year-round and life-long theme is vulnerable love, which we picture best in a manger and on a cross—and that you, my friends, represent in the ways you care for others, listen to another’s heart, lay aside ego for the greater good, forgive generously, communicate honestly but humbly, and pursue Jesus’s peaceful ways with passion without taking yourselves too seriously.  I see the Light of God in each of you.    

YOU are the best sermons anyone ever hears at Open Table.

With love and thankfulness,
Ellen

Sunday, December 23, 2012

The Christmas Chipmunk

 

You might assume that I, a Christian minister, grew up celebrating Christmas in traditional ways, with solemnity and religiosity aplenty.  I did attend my share of Christmas Eve services with my church-going family.  But our family Christmas celebrations have, over the years, included zanier moments, like the annual visit from the Christmas Chipmunk.

You’ve not heard of the Christmas Chipmunk?  Then I’ll begin with the origins of this mythical character. 

While I was in my late teens, my father drove home from work one evening wearing a chipmunk costume.  He’d found the full body costume, like the ones Disney World characters walk around in, which someone discarded at his office. My father decided it would be funny to arrive home incognito.  He knocked on the front door just to see what kind of reaction he’d get.  Since I answered the door, he received a loud reaction.  Though chipmunks are the most adorable of all rodents, the seven-foot variety lose some of their charm when they surprise you at the front door.  After the giant chipmunk calmed me down, the rest of the family thought it would be fun to take turns donning the costume.  Someone ran to get a camera.  Soon we were all excitedly trying on the chipmunk costume and posing for the camera—realizing only after a whole roll of film was wasted that all the pictures of the chipmunk looked exactly alike regardless of who was inside the costume.  This delay of insight should give you a clue about our limited capacity for maintaining holiday decorum.

Years later, again on a whim, my father rediscovered the chipmunk costume on the Christmas Eve when his then only grandchildren, my daughter and my sister’s son, were two years old and visiting with their parents for the holiday.  Following some grandfatherly impulse to entertain, my father secretly costumed himself, went outside, and then knocked on the front door.  My mother, the only other person in on the scheme, answered the door and in her grandmotherliest tone announced, “Oh, goodness, it’s the Christmas Chipmunk!”  She ushered in the visitor, who spoke not a word but waved and smiled his painted-on smile. 

“Georgia.  Alex.  Here’s the Christmas Chipmunk!” their grandmother introduced, as if we’d been expecting him.  “Would you like to come give him a sweet hug? He’s come to see if you’re getting ready for bed so that Santa can come.”

In an instant, the other adults understood the mythology being constructed.  This Christmas Chipmunk was to Santa what John the Baptist was to Jesus:  a forerunner, a harbinger of the real deal.  We caught on to the plot and chimed in with things like, “Thanks for coming to see us, Mr. Chipmunk!  You can tell Santa that we’re going to bed now.  See you next year!”  Although the chipmunk did not exclaim, as he waddled out of sight, “Merry Christmas to all, and to all a good night!” he did wave, and Georgia and Alex, stunned, waved back. 

The chipmunk would visit each Christmas Eve at bedtime for the next ten years.  And as my sister and her husband and then my brother and his wife added more children to the extended family, the Chipmunk’s Christmas Eve audience increased.  Every Christmas Eve the Chipmunk helped our children prepare for Santa’s visit.  And the Chipmunk ritual continued until the costume finally wore out.  And by then the children were past the age of credulity.

But for a few years there, we allowed our children to live in a bizarre subculture that may have scarred them for life.  For you see, my daughter and her cousins assumed that, like Santa, the Christmas Chipmunk, whose story we embellished a bit more each year, was part of everyone’s Christmas.  We parents of these deluded children discovered later that Georgia and cousins would talk with their little friends about Santa’s helper, the Christmas Chipmunk—and these little friends would then look askance at the tales of his annual visitations.  Kindergartners in Nashville, Montgomery, and Tampa then brought tales home to their parents of a deviant celebration of Christmas.

We also exposed our daughter and nephews and niece to other counter-cultural traditions.  Before our family’s annual Christmas Eve reading of the Christmas story from the Gospel of Luke, my sister and I staged the family nativity drama.  When the children were babies, we’d dress them up in ridiculous costumes and pose them for a live nativity scene.  As they grew older, we’d teach them songs, creatively choreographed, to perform in my parents’ family room.  We’d get our pets in the act, too, putting antlers on our dogs when we needed reindeer or draping a dog in a nubby white bath mat when we needed a sheep.  As the children grew even older, they began to produce the pageants themselves, complete with misspelled playbills and homemade costumes.  Georgia one year performed her Christmas piano recital piece, “The Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy,” as cousin Alex manipulated his family’s puppy, dressed in a tiny tutu, into a lovely ballet of that Christmas standard.  Once my nephew Patrick, at about age 6, delivered a spot-on Elvis impersonation while singing “Blue Christmas.”  And my sister and I can still be persuaded to sing in annoying falsetto our impersonation of Alvin and the Chipmunk’s “Christmas, Christmas Time is Here” after which my father annually pronounces with heavy sarcasm, “Makes you proud.”  Incidentally, as far as we know, Alvin is unrelated to the Christmas Chipmunk.

There are times when I do wonder if our silliness is irreligious.  At times I wish my family and I would spend as much time reflecting together on the “serious” message of Christmas as we do planning a punch line.

Then again, maybe it’s best that we not strain at tradition, that we not calculate customs, that they evolve from who we are and what we enjoy and need and how we express love in wide-ranging ways to one another over time.  Maybe traditions need not be so, well, traditional.

Besides—and I hope I’m not simply justifying my own penchant for silliness—playfulness can be holy and healing.  But let me be clear. I’m not recommending humor that is insensitive to others or feeds an attention-starved ego or helps us mask our true self.  Jokes can’t produce Advent joy. Good humor can be truly good only when it’s not at someone else’s expense.  The deepest joy rarely gets expressed in a belly laugh.  Sacred gladness does not gloss over grief or deny depression.  Yet there is a holy joyfulness to the life of faith that helps us be authentic and requires us to become vulnerable, and these are important spiritual dispositions.

I believe there is something freeing about being willing to look foolish.  Think how spiritually daring it is to cast aside any pretense of dignity when you are with the ones you love.  Consider what a gift we give to be extravagantly un-sober in order to prompt a smile.  It is profoundly generous and trusting to fling aside one’s pride to delight another.  I’m stretching the analogy here, I realize, but isn’t loss of dignity what the Christ-child experienced, being disreputably birthed in a stable among a rude audience of sheep and shepherds, who in effect applauded at his abdication of nobility?  Wasn’t it Jesus’s rejection of decorum and tradition that brought him to the manger and then to the cross? 

Let us now return to today’s Gospel reading—where the ridiculous prompts the rejoicing.  Elizabeth, well past childbearing age, is pregnant with her first son, and that improbable child in her womb improbably leaps with joy as Mary approaches—Mary, the preposterous virgin mother.  How wild is that?  Maybe this is what Madeleine L’Engle had in mind as she invites the God of Advent to “Come speak in joy untamed and wild.”


Mary responds to her cousin Elizabeth’s exclamation of joy with her own song of joy we now call the Magnificat.  What a lot we can learn from Mary’s joyful outburst.  First, Mary’s own good fortune is not the chief cause for her happiness.  Though she describes herself as blessed, Mary is celebrating good news for her people.  Those who’ve been hungry will have good things to eat; those who are lowly will be raised up, and the powerful will be brought low.  Mary is ecstatic for the good fortune of others. That capacity to be happy for others is a mark of Gospel joy.

Notice also that Mary’s joy is subversive.  Often humor in the Bible, written for people under political oppression, comes from the idea of turning the tables on those in power. Mary is delighted that the unexpected can happen. The God of the Bible does the unexpected and makes the wise look foolish.  Mary smiles at the preposterous thought that God has favored her—and her child will save a desperate people. 

One writer claims that the Bible is basically a comedy rather a tragedy because comedy works through surprise and ends with celebration.  Comedy is hopeful.  Mary’s song belongs in a musical comedy, you might argue.  Maybe a family Christmas pageant performed by children in bathrobes—and the family dogs in sheep’s clothing—is not so far off the mark.


If you’re able to attend the Christmas Eve service here tomorrow night, you’ll find it a sweet and solemn service.  But listen for the note of joy.  During the reading of the Christmas story, you might imagine the angels in that celestial pageant singing, with halos slightly askew, “Joy to the world, the Lord is come!  So have a good laugh!  Be not afraid, shepherds.  Loosen up!  And do not take yourselves too seriously, you stuffy Magi!”  Author Annie Dillard, who espouses living exultantly with “unseemly joy,” contends that she has “not seen a great deal accomplished in the name of dignity.”  I agree.

Still, I wonder how close hilarity is to heresy. 

Well, it’s too late now for my family.  You’ll have to find that line for yourselves. 

This evening the final Advent candle shines in the name of joy.  In my family, joy looks a lot like hilarity.  I hope that is close enough.


PRAYER  God, help us get good at the spiritual art of joy.  For our sake.  For the sake of this ol’ world.  Amen

Sunday, December 16, 2012

The Light Shines in the Darkness



Worship at Open Table yesterday was a beautiful service of Lessons and Carols.  After the reading of the final lesson from the Gospel of John, I offered these words:


Today is traditionally the Sunday in Advent when we light the candle of Joy. For several reasons I had weeks ago decided that we'd change the order this year and light the candle of Love today, saving the candle of Joy for next Sunday.  Maybe that was prescient. Maybe on this Sunday we need the focus on God's love.  And maybe joy will be a word we can hear later.  

The cookie baking party with eleven creative, loving, and delightful children yesterday was certainly joyful, and it was one way we could do what our President recommended on Friday: That we all "hug our children a little tighter and . . . tell them that we love them, and . . . remind each other how deeply we love one another."  That is, of course, what we as a faith community try to do each and every time we gather.  How we grieve for those who are this day unable to hold their children close.

Hear now these Gospel words from John 1:1-5.

In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. He was in the beginning with God. All things came into being through him, and without him not one thing came into being. What has come into being in him was life, and the life was the light of all people. The light shines in the darkness, and the darkness did not overcome it.

Our Lessons and Carols service this evening will soon conclude as we sing “Silent Night” while lighting our individual candles from the flame of the Advent candle of Love. Though our individual candles may glow feebly, we find hope in Gospel assurance that God’s light shines in the darkness and the darkness did not—and will not—overcome it.  We believe this Gospel truth.

Yet our hearts are left to ponder the imponderable.  Since last Friday’s news from Connecticut, you and I have struggled to fathom the unfathomable, to explain the inexplicable. Our minds search for answers and solutions.  And indeed we need to use brain cells and human resources and political will to reduce violence.  We must look at gun control legislation and mental health interventions.  We must examine the media’s role and even, as one source I read yesterday asserts, recognize that white Americans often assume violence is “out there” and thus miss signs of violence in white communities.  We need wide-ranging research and courageous leadership. 

We do NOT, as people of faith, need to fall back on religious platitudes that dodge responsibility and eschew good sense—as, unfortunately, Mike Huckabee did in theorizing the Newtown shooting was the result of taking God out of our schools.  Our commitment to nonviolence requires the problem-solving of good minds.

But let us ground smart thinking and courageous action in a spirituality that says the answer is within our hearts, too.  We must begin with a place of compassion for all and with a faith in God’s love.  Our trust is not in guns. Our faith is not in the Second Amendment.  We will not sacrifice any more precious ones to the God of Violence.  We will not.

On this evening it is fitting that the Advent Candle of Love is lighting the way.  In the vast darkness that falls around us, that one candle seems inconsequential.  But by that one candle we can light other candles—as we will in a few moments.  By attending to the voice of love within, we can carry our one light into the world, and know we are not alone, know we can help light the flame of love in others.

Kyrie Eleison.

I share now a link that I've passed along to my congregation to aid parents as their children begin to hear about the tragedy in Newtown, CT.   

http://www.nj.com/helpinghands/goodgrief/index.ssf/2012/12/supporting_children_after_sand.html .