Monday, July 30, 2012

Be Kind to the Mind


Once a quarter, the Sunday service at Open Table (United Church of Christ) features the story of one of our members or participants.  On "fifth Sundays" a volunteer shares with us a story from her or his faith journey.  We cultivate storytelling as a spiritual practice because we are storytelling creatures. Telling our stories is a way of doing the inner work of reflecting spiritually and the outer work of connecting to others.  We help hear one another into awareness of God's work in our own lives, and we listen in these sacred moments to ways we can join in God's work in the world.  These stories always seem to include experiences of pain or challenge as well as increased compassion and hope.

But these stories are often difficult to tell and meant for our community alone, stories shared among a people where trust has been established.  

Last night we were honored that one of our own shared with us the story of her struggle with mental illness.  We heard of the terrors experienced from delusional thinking and visual hallucinations.  We learned of a ten-year struggle to find the right medications and overcome the burdensome stigma of mental illness, of one caring doctor who "never gave up" in those ten long years, and of a faithful life partner, too.  And we received important facts about the prevalence of mental illness that cuts across all demographic categories.

Thankfully, our society at last is being more enlightened about mental illnesses and disorders and less skittish about discussing and disclosing them.  We are hopeful that medical research is coming ever closer to understanding and addressing, for instance, the skyrocketing number of children being diagnosed with autism, and of elders dealing with Alzheimer's.  We pray for for treatments to help teens and adults experiencing eating disorders and drug addictions and postpartum depression and bi-polar disorder and alcoholism.   

The Justice and Witness Ministry of the UCC advocates for mental health.  Our denomination has declared: “Good health is part of God's intention for all people. Health involves the whole person, body, mind, and spirit. Health is a concern of the whole community and healing and health care are valid ways of proclaiming the gospel and ministering in the name of Jesus Christ.”

In lieu of a sermon, I share today the link to an article by a neuropsychologist that offers all of us a practical perspective on ways to minimize harm that can come to our minds and bodies.  I've preached before on themes related to facing into our pain rather than remaining in denial.  This article does not contradict that point but balances it helpfully, I believe.  It came to me through the wonderful Charter for Compassion, which I follow on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/CharterforCompassion .  

Here is the article by Dr. Rick Hanson:


Just One Thing: Minimize Painful Experiences
http://greatergood.berkeley.edu/article/item/just_one_thing_minimize_painful_experiences

Sunday, July 22, 2012

Crossing the Edmund Pettus Bridge


Sermon Text:  Ephesians 2:14-22

Friday before last, George and I crossed the Alabama River into the city of Selma by way of the infamous Edmund Pettus Bridge.  Suspended beneath the steel archway glinting above us and the water flowing darkly below, we were crossing into another place and time to do some bridge building of our own.

Named for a Confederate officer, the Edmund Pettus Bridge was constructed to connect people on opposite banks of the Alabama River. But on a day in 1965, a day that would become known as Bloody Sunday, that bridge morphed into a wall.  On one side of the wall were peaceful citizens marching for the right to vote.  On the other side of the wall was the highway to the state capital and the powerful ones who could grant them this right.  In the middle, armed law enforcement officers blocked the civil rights marchers on the river’s east side, closing off access to the Montgomery highway and beating women and men trying to cross that bridge--trying to BE that bridge--to a united Alabama.  It would take two more attempts later that month and even more bloodshed before the Edmund Pettus Wall was “broken down.” Only then could the Edmund Pettus Bridge be a genuine sign of God’s eternal enterprise that is making us into--using words from Ephesians--“one new humanity in the place of two.”



One does not easily cross the Edmund Pettus Bridge. Even 47 years later. Especially if you grew up in Alabama.  Especially if you grew up in Selma. 

So there we were, 47 years after Bloody Sunday, 40 years after George graduated from Selma High School. We had traveled to Selma to attend the first real high school reunion the class of 1972 had ever held.  We came mainly because we learned the class reunion organizers were aiming to bridge some lingering divides.
  
Apparently a few partial reunions had been held over the years, but they’d been small and (intentionally or not) racially segregated affairs.  Maybe this was because in pre-Facebook times there was no easy way to contact alumni, many of whom had moved away, and because the alumni had thought of themselves as a “class” only briefly.  The white and black students who graduated together in 1972 had attended racially segregated schools until 1970, so the Selma Saints of ’72, 60 percent black and 40 percent white, had planned their senior prom together and played on the football team together and served on the student council together, but their togetherness looked at times like a carefully negotiated treaty or an awkward if mostly polite social experiment.

We know that Selma, Alabama, did not invent racism; that prejudice is found in all regions of our country; that hatred hides in every human heart.  But in 1965, Selma became the poster city for racism.  George and his classmates have carried the legacy of their hometown history with them—on their professional resumes, into casual conversations with strangers on planes —and have borne the judgment that sometimes follows.  You experience it, too, don’t you--when you travel to Boston or San Francisco and your accent betrays you and you finally disclose you’re from Alabama?  But just try naming Selma as your hometown. Selma happens to be both an ignominious symbol and a very real place inhabited by all kinds of people, good and bad and in between.

George learned this reunion was being planned mainly by African American classmates.  He also heard that few white classmates were planning to attend.  To be more accurate, he heard that most of the white classmates who still lived in Selma were opting out. Now there are lots of good reasons not to attend a high school reunion.  And it's impossible to know another's motives.  But some white classmates who’d moved away—who’d permanently crossed the Edmund Pettus Bridge themselves—began making plans to attend the reunion.

It became important for George to be a part of that kind of reunion.

But to be honest and to get straight to my point—breaking down those dividing walls is hard and unending work.  Despite our best intentions, we who attended the festivities did not always engage in that work successfully.

Unfortunately, George and I may have accidentally triggered plans for what became an all-white pre-reunion dinner on Friday night.  The reunion itself was to kick off with light refreshments and drinks at a reception at the historic St. James Hotel at 7:00.  We wanted to have dinner first, so George invited a former classmate to meet us at a restaurant before the reception.  Soon that person invited others and eventually someone reserved a private room for twenty former classmates. All white. We hadn’t intended to be a “whites only” group.  But forty years ago the white kids had been friends with white kids.  Ironically, the only place in Selma for such a group to dine was a private dinner club, the tired but pretentiously named “The Tallyho,” whose purpose forty years earlier was to provide Selma’s white citizens with a legal way to maintain a segregated restaurant. 
  
We gazed around the table that evening to find only white faces in an establishment historically associated with segregation.  As that irony was dawning on some of us, we wondered aloud why the white classmates who still live in Selma weren’t planning to attend the reunion.  Our tacit assumption as the white out-of-towners—maybe not a fair one—was that some of the people who had stayed in Selma had retained old prejudices. One woman at dinner theorized that only those who’d moved away from Selma were able to get enough distance on the culture to reject racism and return in a spirit of reconciliation.  Another countered it had been their racial integration experience in high school that had itself caused a major shift in their worldview, which in turn caused them to leave Selma all those years ago. Which might have been a cause and which an effect?  Recognizing racism or leaving Selma?  Our analysis came to a pause as an African American waiter refilled our glasses.  We drank in the realization that, however inadvertently, we had begun the reunion by re-constructing a wall.

Upon arriving at the St. James, we consciously sought out African American peers.  George and I listened to stories of personal successes and well-lived lives and felt happy for folks who had risen above the expectations of those times. As we gathered on a balcony and looked down on the Alabama River below, words and feelings flowed easily, genially.

In some conversations among the former Selma High Saints, we lamented that only about thirty white classmates had decided to come. But as we did so, we’d looked up from a freshly formed conversation group to realize we had moved back into the old race-based groupings, as if the black and white classmates were the proverbial oil and water.  We would create that night a mixed-race conversation group for a while, but soon a new person would enter our group and another person would leave it and before we knew it, we had separated again into all black or all white groupings.  Over and over we saw before us the evidence that it is a harder engineering feat to build a bridge than a wall.  

Some segregation, based on fear and prejudice, is methodically deliberate and hurtful. Some segregation-- born of habit, convenience, legitimate need, or chance--is unintended, even inevitable and morally neutral.  I’m not saying we should have engineered a social event into a human resource workshop.  High school reunions are not the way to right personal or societal wrongs. And I admit that, as a spouse to a Selma Saint, I was an outsider to an event I'm oversimplifying now to express what I personally needed to understand more deeply: a not-so-new realization about the intransigence of racism..  

We at Open Table aspire to be a multiracial church where all feel welcome. There IS great diversity among us.  But wouldn’t we all want to see even greater racial and ethnic diversity here?

The writer to the church at Ephesus urged those Jesus followers to bring together Jews and Gentiles as one humanity.  Glance back at today’s focal scripture. I’m going to gloss it as if it were written, not to Christians in Ephesus in the first century, but to Christians in Selma in 1965 or 1972—or to Mobilians in 2012:
14Jesus Christ is the embodiment of peace; in his flesh—that is, in his body, in the disparate parts of the body of Christ, which is the church--he has made both groups (black and white, rich and poor, gay and straight, citizens and undocumented immigrants) into one. The Jesus way of peace has broken down the dividing wall, that is, the hostility between you.  15The Spirit of Peace took away the old hostilities supported, for instance, by Jim Crow laws that kept you segregated. God made you into one humanity, and the ongoing experience of the living Christ continues to teach you that you can experience the peace of God within and without because you have access to one and the same Spirit.  Begin by knowing God's peace within. Only then can you live in peace with others. 16And Christ reconciled both groups in one body within God's love through the cross—the cross being one of those places where God-directed ones side with the marginalized and refuse to return violence with violence. Jesus' cross was nonviolent protest on a cosmic level. Thus Divine Love put to death that hostility through a radical symbol of love—which, unfortunately, the KKK later set afire to create their symbol of hate. 17But Jesus proclaimed peace to you who were far off and peace to you who were near; 18for through him both groups have equal access in one Spirit to the Source of Love. 19So you are no longer strangers and aliens, but you are all equal in God’s eyes. You are equally Selma High Saints and, more importantly, you are all also equal members of God's family, living in a house 20 whose foundation was built by God lovers who’ve gone before you and with Christ Jesus himself as the cornerstone. The cornerstone does not create barriers; instead, it brings people together. It joins a structure21 which then grows into a sacred site 22 where we are built together spiritually into a dwelling place for God. When we can come together, and put aside hostilities, and give up the categories of black and white, us versus them, gay or straight . . .  we become that place where God takes up residence!

It’s not easy.  Even when we stop overt hostilities, we must, by God's grace, give up the cruelty of indifference, the selfishness of inertia, the assumption that someone else will build the bridge, the delusion that racism or the other evil isms and phobias are gone. Building bridges takes intentionality, responsibility, courage, vigilance.  

And it takes time.

Contrast, if you will, the Edmund Pettus Bridge with the Living Bridges of Meghalaya, India.  


As this video will explain, for hundreds of years the inhabitants of this remote region have trained trees to grow into bridges that cross raging rivers otherwise unbridgeable during the monsoon season. 

http://www.wimp.com/livingbridge

With constant cultivation, the trees’ tangled root systems keep the banks of the rivers from washing out.  Villagers bend and intertwine roots that sprout above ground level so they eventually connect to trees on the opposite bank and so form bridges that can hold the weight of 50 adults.  This network of dozens of living bridges connects the valleys of Meghalaya. The bridges can last up to 500 years if maintained.  But maintaining the bridges is never-ending work.  The video shows a man teaching his young niece the art of tending and guiding the roots. He tells her, “Your children will use it and your children’s children.  It will grow for generations.”  He explains that it is she who must continue building this particular bridge after he is gone because no person can complete the task in one life time. 
 
No one person and no one generation will ever complete the bridges our culture needs.  We must show our children how to be bridge builders.  We must be spiritual engineers and architects throughout our lives:  breaking down the walls, creating living bridges, making of our collective lives a temple where Christ is the joining cornerstone and where the Spirit of Love dwells.

PRAYER
God, let us be a bridge of care connecting people everywhere.
Help us confront all fear and hate and lust for power that separate.*

*from Ruth Duck's hymn "Diverse in Culture, Nation, Race"

Monday, July 9, 2012

Sabbath Time

For 53 consecutive weeks I've posted on this blogsite my weekly sermon to my congregation, but I'm vacationing this week. A colleague in ministry preached at Open Table yesterday and will do so again this coming Sunday.

If you have been following this blogsite, thank you. If you want to read a sermon from "That Preacher Woman" this week, you might choose for this week a previously posted sermon.  Thanks to all who have been supportive of the ministry of Open Table UCC.

Thanks to  Rev. Bart McNiel for filling the pulpit at Open Table.

Thanks to the beautiful and beloved members of Open Table: A Community of Faith (United Church of Christ) in Mobile, Alabama, for their receptiveness to a voice for progressive Christianity. 

Ellen

Monday, July 2, 2012

JESUSCARE

Text: Mark 5: 21-43
     Today’s Gospel reading gives us more detail, pathos, and suspense than usual from the terse writer of Mark.   How can our hearts not go out to a dying twelve-year-old girl—and to her father, so desperate to save her that he, an important synagogue leader, falls prostrate before Jesus?  How can we not be a bit repelled—let’s be honest—by a woman with an embarrassing gynecological condition, a woman ostracized for being ritually unclean, a woman who waylays Jesus as he's en route to the child?

As I think about Jesus being called, simultaneously, to heal two desperate people in two separate locations, I think of the classic superhero dilemma. You know. Where the bad guy creates two mutually irresolvable disasters, and Superman or Spiderman (yes, comic books require a male hero) must decide if he will save the woman he loves or an entire city doomed for destruction.  He can’t be in two places at one time.  Neither can Jesus—who’s not even a real superhero.

Then I think about my own limitations, and yours, as we join Jesus in healing a wounded world.  Must I as a minister of the Gospel, must we as a caring congregation, must all of us as citizens of this nation whose founding we celebrate in three days—must we do triage to help the few we can?  Must we admit our personal, congregational, and societal limits in order to do some bit of good, or else waste our efforts on those beyond saving, or quit trying altogether?  

I suppose this week’s top headline brought the problem of human limitations to the forefront of this Gospel reading for me.  You know the headline I’m talking about but which CNN and FOX news both got wrong when they first broadcast it on Thursday. I’m talking about the Supreme Court’s ruling that the Affordable Care Act IS constitutional.  With all the attention on what some derisively call Obamacare and its promises of universal healthcare, I’ve tried to imagine what Jesuscare looks like.   So I’ve looked with fresh eyes at today’s stories about Jesus’ health care plan for the kingdom of God. 

Not that I think the Bible contains instructions for reforming health care in America.  But Mark’s Gospel says an awful lot about healing.  And I do find in today’s paired healing stories something that prods me to ask about the personal and systemic limits we face in addressing problems today as U.S. citizens and as modern followers of Jesus.

On the surface, this Gospel passage suggests there are no limitations on Jesus’s healing.  Everyone, it seems, has access to his miraculous power: from the twelve-year-old daughter of the prestigious synagogue leader to a woman considered ritually unclean because for twelve years she suffered from menstrual bleeding.  Both the privileged and the pariahs are healed.  Both the petted and the pathetic.  Yes, even gynecological issues are covered under Jesus’ health care benefits.  Even a woman abused by the previous health care system that had, the story says, taken her very last penny but had left her sicker than before.  Even a woman with the “preexisting condition” of a twelve-year-old illness.  (The number twelve repeated in this story, by the way, signifies completeness, fullness, as in the twelve tribes of Israel, as in the twelve disciples.)  Jesus’s plan seems to cover everyone fully.  Even the desperately poor.  Even a seemingly incurable woman all other physicians have failed to cure.  Even a seemingly dead girl.  I’d call that universal health care.

But surely there are limits to the resources that support Jesus’ health care system.   True, he heals many. But he didn’t heal everyone in the enormous crowds clamoring for his care.  How many others never got close enough to see him, much less to touch his garment?  How many others called out to him in vain? And what was the cost to him and his followers for these healings?

Jesus himself knew human limitations.  He was not a nonstop healing machine.  At times he had to withdraw from the crowds to replenish his body and spirit.  As I gratefully anticipate the first week of vacation I’ve had in a year, I understand the need to withdraw for a while.  But I wonder . . . whose suffering went unrelieved while Jesus rested?  Mark’s Gospel shows Jesus growing overwhelmed by the crowds.  By this point in Mark’s narrative, readers start realizing Jesus is not going to be able to keep at it much longer.  If you try to heal everyone, then your limited resources—physical or financial or spiritual—will run out, right?

Let’s peek ahead in Mark to see if that’s the case. Immediately following today’s two stories of healing, Mark tells us Jesus traveled to his hometown of Nazareth—where it turned out that he tried but “he could do no deed of power there” (Mark 6:5), and Jesus’s skeptical homies scoffed at this prophet who was without honor in his hometown (Mark 6:4). 

Jesus had limitations.  But just because our resources are finite does not mean they are ineffective. Limited beings can still be powerful and generous and selfless and, indeed, innovative and collaborative.  Notice what Jesus does next to make his healing ministry sustainable.

Immediately after disappointing his hometown, Jesus implemented the next phase of his ministry, which was to instruct and then send out his disciples “two by two” (Mark 6:7) and Mark tells us they “cast out many demons and anointed with oil many who were sick and cured them” (Mark 6:13).  An episode of failure perhaps created a paradigm shift for Jesus.  A healing ministry becomes sustainable only when others are empowered to participate as healers. 

For us, new church, this means that our growth, impact, and sustainability are tied to our willingness to share leadership and train others in the healing ways of Jesus and include all in a ministry of hope.  A Jesus model of leadership starts with a healer, who taps and trains others, who further maximizes the healing impact by equipping still others.  Members of our new church council will be talking with you soon as they seek to share leadership with you. Healing happens best in community. Today’s hymn expresses this idea as a prayer: “Healer of our every ill . . . teach us ALL your way of healing.”

For folks like us, raised in an individualistic and competitive culture, a dying child and hemorrhaging woman might seem to be competing for limited health resources, and we may feel pressed to choose which one gets our care.  We might be susceptible to inflammatory threats of "death panels."  Certainly resources are limited.  Hard choices have to be made.  Caring for our neighbors is not a license to be fiscally irresponsible.  I’m not so idealistic that I don’t get that. I don’t want my grandchildren to bear the burden of debt I help create. We must consider those who are not yet on this planet.  And there are many ways of understanding how we can do that best.

Yet I believe this also to be true: we have more than we think we have. We can cooperate to equip others to be healers of broken communities. That’s what the story of the feeding of the 5,000 teaches a few verses later.  If we don’t grasp our own fish and bread too tightly, then all will have enough.  We don’t have limitless resources—as a church, as a nation, as a planet.  But we have enough if we are compassionate.    If we prioritize care for one another, maybe my good health does not have to cost you your health.  If we can hear the words of Jesus to Jairus, the distraught father: “Do not fear; only believe," then healing can happen.

Even within our own congregation, if we all give in ways that truly challenge us, so that our giving then changes us, so that  we practice giving as an essential spiritual discipline, so that we cultivate gratitude and generosity, so that we don’t deplete some leaders without ever engaging others—then everyone receives what she or he needs.  If we as a faith community take turns serving and being served, giving and receiving, the healing ministry of Jesus is continued in a sustainable way.

Another way of facing the limits—within America’s newly upheld healthcare system or within Jesuscare—is to ask if our healing mission should be broadly or narrowly focused?  How specific is Jesus’s mission statement?  I’m told that a really good mission statement is precise enough to guide an organization in every decision it makes.  But Jesus’s great commandment to love God, neighbor, and self seems broad.  And I wonder if today’s story suggests Jesus himself got diverted at times. 

I hope he did.  I think he did.  What I love best about this story is that Jesus is on his way to help one person but gets detoured by another who reached out to him, and he paused long enough to do the deeper healing of her soul.  He said he was going to do one thing, but he ended up doing another.

Have you ever taken a detour in life?  Have you ever set out with one intention and ended up doing something else that turned out to be a more joyous or satisfying or healing experience than the original might have been?  Some of us are the ADHD- types who are too interruptible.  Others of us are too inflexible.  Today’s story tells me that Jesus probably knew what if felt like to be buffeted by all those clamoring for  help. Seems he both improvised and stayed the course.

We as a congregation have a mission statement that grounds us.  It’s written on the front of every worship bulletin and it does truly guide us in our ongoing discernment in how to be the church God is calling us to be.  But we can’t hear a Still Speaking God if we pour concrete around those words.

At last week's retreat, the church council generated three simple themes for the coming church year: growth, service, and leadership.  You’ll hear more about what these three words mean to us as Jenni leads our 6:00 discussion hour. You’ll also have a chance to share your hopes and dreams for the coming year with our new council members there to listen to you.  A clear mission or focus for a church, and for a particular year in the life of that church, is a good thing. 

But let’s stay relational more than organizational. Let’s be strategic but let’s also be at times spontaneous. Let’s remain alert enough to notice when a suffering soul pushes her way into our midst. 

I encourage you to study the issues of the day, but whatever your opinions about Obamacare—I invite you to ground yourself in Jesuscare.  It’s a healthcare plan for the whole person—body, mind, and spirit. 

Today we are blessing the work of a new church council.  But all of us are, in Jesuscare, both the healed and the healer. All of us can identify with someone in this story:  We have rushed a child to an emergency room and can feel the father’s terror.  We have depended on others for care and compassion and empathize with a sick and ostracized woman. We have overextended ourselves for the good of family or community and can imagine Jesus’s possible feelings of exhaustion and inadequacy.

Yet in this story, Jesus accomplishes the superhero feat: he saves both the woman on the seashore and the child in the village.  And somehow the story teller’s repeated details running through both stories suggest that saving one is not in conflict with saving the other. In fact, these two healings may be inextricably connected.  Jesus, for instance, seems to have Jairus’ little daughter in mind even while he addresses the hemorrhaging woman as “daughter.” Listen to Jesus’s closing cryptic words: “Daughter, your faith has made you well; go in peace, and be healed of your disease.”

Did you catch that odd contradiction?  Jesus says the woman’s faith has already healed her.  And then adds, “Go . . . and be healed.” 

Maybe Jesuscare is ongoing and complex. 

Maybe the kind of healing that Jesus offers is never complete until the entire community is healed and whole. 

May it be so, O God.

INVITATION TO THE TABLE
Today’s gospel story ends with Jesus telling the little girl’s family to give her something to eat.  Healing is complete when we come to the Table.  Eating in that day was a communal event, often a celebratory rite.  Like a child who has been resurrected, we participate now in celebrating resurrection.  Arise!

Sunday, June 24, 2012

Forecast: Stormy, With a Chance of Calm


Texts:  Job 38: 1-18  and Mark 4: 35-41

Hurricane season started early this year, and we are currently under a Tropical Storm Warning with Tropical Storm Debby due south of us. Not a bad time to recall the story of Jesus calming the storm on the Sea of Galilee.   But before we can appreciate what calm feels like, let’s recall the feel of a storm. 

Tori Murden McClure knows more than most of us about storms at sea.  In 1999, she became the first woman to row across an ocean.   Yes.  I said row.  Without a motor.  Without a sail.  Without a companion.  In a wooden row boat, she rowed across the Atlantic for over 3 months straight, 10 hours, 12 hours, sometimes 16 grueling hours a day, each and every day, except during the most violent of weather. 

Tori had attempted this feat the previous year but had to be rescued some 900 miles shy of the coast of France after a 3-month voyage that included arduous exertion and deprivation, equipment failure and total isolation; injuries and narrow escapes from catastrophe; the failure of her long distance communication system and the assault of two hurricanes.  In her memoir, A Pearl in the Storm,[i] Tori McClure describes her first realization that the storm (which she later learned was Hurricane Danielle) would be more fearsome than anything she’d previously endured:

“Sept. 5.  The wind generated by the storm was stronger than anything I’d ever experienced, and the waves were bigger than anything I had imagined.  I’d been through some nasty gales, and I considered anything over 25-feet really big.  These waves went well beyond really big.  They were the size of buildings.  . . .  Huddled in the dark, I reached for [and then spoke to] the video camera:  “I’m in by far the most violent storm that I’ve been in so far. . . .  I’m not sure I’m going to make it through this one’” (155).

By that time Tori was jammed into her coffin of a cabin.  Only a few feet high, the cabin gave her barely enough room in which to lie down but not enough to sit upright.  She could, however, close the hatch overhead to seal in oxygen for herself  and to aid the little boat’s ability to right itself when capsized—which happened more than a dozen times over the next two days of violent weather. 

Tori’s narrative continues: “By sunrise, the water in my cabin was several inches deep . . . The waves hit with so much force that pinhole leaks sprayed like fine water jets.  Because I couldn’t sit upright, the water sloshed around my back and shoulders.  . . My boat felt like a bathtub toy in the hands of an angry 2-year-old.  As much as the earsplitting wail of wind terrified, the periodic silences were worse.  The wind was quiet only when an approaching wave was tall enough to block it out. Like ghostly fingers, the quiet moments pointed to the walls of water that were about to hammer me.  The lull never lasted more than a few seconds” (156).

“At around 7:00 am, I heard the rumble of an approaching breaker.  An avalanche of white foam was followed by the slam of a wrecking ball.  I clawed at the walls and ceiling trying to get a grip.  The only things louder than the roar of that wave were the yelps of my pain.  The boat rolled, and I flipped head over heels.  The boat spun on its bottom and rolled again, tossing me heels over head.  Wood, fiberglass, flesh, and bone interacted in unnatural ways. . . . The boat shook for a moment and then flipped upright so quickly I didn’t have time to think about landing.  My body spun in the air, and my twisted torso landed on the floor with a harsh thwack. It was my first capsize of the day, and this was just the beginning” (157).

Soon McClure was a mess of blood, bruises, and broken bones.  She wanted to set off the 406-megahertz international distress beacon by then—but she refused to put potential rescuers in harm’s way.  So she rode out many more terrifying hours.  At one point she again spoke into her video camera:  “I have a strange sense of peace at this point.  I don’t know what it means.’” More hours later, having gone into and out of and back into and out of the path of Danielle, the worst was over.  But with the boat listing heavily toward starboard and nearly in pieces, Tori at last set off the distress signal.  Rescue was finally on the way.

By comparison, the disciples of Jesus seem a little wimpy and a tad premature in setting off their “distress signal.”  Of course, Mark’s terse Gospel relates few details about their ordeal at sea, so it’s hard to work up much sympathy for them. 

Here’s what we are told. After teaching large crowds about the realm of God, parable by parable—including the parable of the mustard seed we read last Sunday—Jesus suggested to his disciples that they get away from the crowds by sailing across the Sea of Galilee.  Unfortunately, some of the crowd followed in their boats.  So maybe Jesus would not get much peace and quiet on the opposite shore either.  And, as it turned out, the sea would not be peaceful either. As happens on the Sea of Galilee, a storm came up suddenly.  Great waves were swamping the boat.  Yet the distressed disciples found Jesus snoozing in the stern.

Biblical commentators don’t know what to make of this.  Some speculate that Jesus sleeping through the storm signals how utterly depleted he was from the demands of the crowds.  Some wonder if Jesus feigned sleep to test the disciples’ faith.  Some think Jesus’s nap was not a factual detail but a literary device, specifically an allusion to Jonah, also discovered sleeping in the hull of a ship during a storm.  You’ll recall that Jonah saved his traveling companions by volunteering to give himself up to the sea.  In contrast, Jesus saved those in his boat by speaking the sea into calm.  Further, the 3 days Jesus spent in the tomb have been compared to the 3 days Jonah spent in the belly of the whale.  You’ll also recall God had told Jonah to bring good news to the Gentiles in Ninevah.  In today’s story Jesus was sailing from primarily Jewish territory to the primarily Gentile territory on the opposite side of the Sea of Galilee. Mark therefore may have added the detail of Jesus sleeping through the storm to remind us of Jonah, who may suggest to us that Jesus is that line of other prophets called to continue God’s universal care for all people, Jew and Gentile alike. 

Of course, the disciples in the story interpreted Jesus’ sleep to mean he did not care a flip about them. But by now Mark’s readers should be skeptical of the disciples’ point of view.  After all, the writer of Mark never misses a chance to show the disciples’ cluelessness.  Therefore, careful readers of Mark suspect that it just seems to the disciples that Jesus doesn’t care.  Maybe once again Jesus’ closest companions and leaders-in-training misperceive the situation or misperceive him.  In fact, Mark’s Gospel is rhetorically successful in part because you and I are able to identify with the imperfect apostles who consistently misunderstand Jesus.  In this instance, I suspect you and I can easily think of times in our own lives when it has indeed SEEMED that God didn’t care.  We know how that feels.  But now we have to wonder if our perspective was skewed.  Might we—like Job—be limited in our ability to judge that which is ultimate and beyond human knowing?  Might we—like the disciples—be misunderstanding Jesus?

After all, maybe we have embarked on this voyage with Jesus with expectations about the journey based on misunderstandings about the ways of God.  Maybe like Job we assumed God was a superhero booming boasts from the whirlwind.  Maybe like the disciples we have assumed that God works through might and magic.  Maybe our expectations of Jesus are about as primitive as those who believed that lightning bolts are hurled down from the heavens by the gods above.  So maybe this story tells us that the God we come to know in Jesus is not Thor or Zeus or even some biblical portraits of Yahweh.

It’s understandable that humans first conceived of God in those terms, of course. Most early cultures imaged a God of he thunder and lightning who was often the chief god in their pantheon.  The Greeks had Zeus; the Scandinavians had Thor; the Hindus had Indra; the Lakotas, Haoka.  Of course early people imagined that lightning was the superior weapon of the greatest god. Of course warrior cultures conceived of their gods as ruling by might and domination.

But Jesus’s power doesn't seem to work that way.  Jesus’s upends our expectations.  His power is of a different sort.  He does not impose his will upon others.  He does not use force.   He does not exact homage.  He does not demand tribute.  Unlike most earthly rulers and mythological beings, Jesus wields power from love alone.  Jesus’s power is nonviolent and noncoercive.  Jesus’s power springs from and leads to peace.  Jesus power is at the core of who he is.

If we interpret the story of Jesus calming the seas like the childish disciples, we may see Jesus working a magic trick and think the seas “obeyed” Jesus’s command.  But if we can instead appreciate the love and faith Jesus lived and taught, we see this story as yet another parable, an enacted parable, about the kingdom of God.  God’s way is revealed through a man who has such reservoirs of trust and love within him that calmness ripples out from his inner core like a quieting countercurrent against the waves of fear. Thus, he stills the hearts of the frightened.  He sleeps undisturbed by the storms of life.  He speaks words of peace—to human hearts and into creation’s chaos.  This is the dramatized parable of one man so imperturbable that his sheer presence neutralized the anxiety striking his disciples like wave after wave threatening to overwhelm them.  No thunderbolts needed.  Jesus rescued his fearful followers by the sheer calm he carried within.

If Christian theology says anything it is this: that Jesus is the very picture and parable of God’s love.  The God we know in Jesus—in this enacted parable on the raging seas or in the spoken parables he continually told the pressing crowds that would have threatened anyone else’s composure—this God is no hurler of thunderbolts, no zapper of sinners, nor manipulator of mortals.  The disciples expected Jesus to outzap the storm gods, to DO something.  Instead, Jesus WAS something.  Jesus was a presence of Divine Compassion.  We don’t have to grovel for that compassion; we don’t fight or strive for that calm. When we live in the oneness we call Christ, we are grounded in that which is unshakable.  We carry it within us across the seas, stormy or calm. 

Sometimes like Tori McClure we face terrors from which we think we won’t survive.  Yet even in moments of despair we hear a voice saying, “Peace.  Be still.”  It is the sheer presence of Jesus with us that is the essence of divine power.  Even within the storm we can experience, as Tori McLure said, “a strange sense of peace” even if we “don’t know what it means.” 

PRAYER:  God who quiets our hearts and stills our racing minds, we don’t know what it all means.  Like Job, we want to challenge you.  But we actually are challenging our feeble idea of you.  Like the first disciples, we want you to smooth out all the rough seas that lie before us.  But we actually need to find the calm within.  In Christ Jesus, in whom we live and move and have our being, we find that resting place.  But like the disciples we still wonder who Jesus is. Help us see how you work through love alone.  Help us forsake the God of Power and Might for the God of Love and Peace.  Amen



[i] Tori Murden McClure, A Pearl in the Storm: How I Found My Heart in the Middle of the Ocean, (New York: HarperCollins, 2009). 

See footage of McClure's voyage: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jco6avrlfHc

Sunday, June 17, 2012

A Guided Meditation: Choosing and Using the Unchoosable and Unusable

                                               Van Gogh's "The Sower," 1888
1 Samuel 15:34-16:13       
Mark 4: 26-34
He also said, "The kingdom of God is as if someone would scatter seed on the ground, and would sleep and rise night and day, and the seed would sprout and grow, he does not know how. The earth produces of itself, first the stalk, then the head, then the full grain in the head. But when the grain is ripe, at once he goes in with his sickle, because the harvest has come." He also said, "With what can we compare the kingdom of God, or what parable will we use for it? It is like a mustard seed, which, when sown upon the ground, is the smallest of all the seeds on earth; yet when it is sown it grows up and becomes the greatest of all shrubs, and puts forth large branches, so that the birds of the air can make nests in its shade."

God’s ways are not our ways.  The full force of love breaks into this world when, for instance, the very least and last of eight sons of Jesse becomes the king (1 Samuel 15:34-16:13).  God’s way materializes before our eyes when a tiny seed becomes a large plant (Mark 4: 26-34).  God chooses the littlest, the lowliest, the least.  

If God were the team captain in a playground game of kickball, she would choose her team by passing over the biggest kid in the class and overlooking the fastest runner and being unimpressed by the most popular boy and caring nothing about who’s wearing the coolest running shoes.  Instead—if God were a ten-year-old choosing a kickball team on the playground--she would shout the name of Herman as her very first choice.  “Herman!” she’d yell as she’d wave that stunned and scrawny thing  to stand next to her.  Yes, Herman: the kid everyone else expected to be chosen last, the friendless oddball who just moved from Podunk, Mississippi.  And here’s the “kicker” to my kickball parable.  Although Herman, the runt of the playground, would look confused at first, and would stumble over his worn out tennis shoes to stand with the growing line of the misfits on the God Team, Herman would blossom into the MVP for his team, thanks to some excellent coaching by God. Like the tiny mustard seed.  Like little David, the shepherd boy.  Like Mary, the mother of Jesus.  Like Jesus.  Like you and me.  Herman would be walking proof that God’s greatness is made known in our weakness.

God chooses and uses the unchoosable and the unusable.  God even chooses and uses those who actually downright unwelcomed and unwanted.  God is like those artists who transform recycled old tires and tin cans into gorgeous sculptures. 

The problem with my kickball analogy is that it implies that God’s realm has an orderliness contradicted by our Gospel reading for today, the parable of the mustard seed.  The irony of that parable is lost on us if we’re not aware that the shrub produced by the mustard seed was an invasive weed.  The sower is planting the Middle Eastern equivalent of kudzu.  About the same time the Gospel of Mark was written, Pliny the Elder wrote in his Natural History that "mustard, [which] is extremely beneficial for the health, . . . grows entirely wild, though it is improved by being transplanted: but on the other hand when it has once been sown it is scarcely possible to get the place free of it, as the seed when it falls germinates at once."   

The realm of God that Jesus preached was being compared to the potentially health-enhancing and shade-producing mustard plant, but the mustard plant tends to take off and take over and then, well, who knows how the landscape might change?  The kingdom of God grows in just that way.  Health and healing may come from it. The wild birds will find shade in it.  Vulnerable creatures will be protected through it.  But something unpredictable and untamable might be set in motion.

Isn’t that what we fear about the realm of God?  I mean, it’s one thing to let Herman on the team.  We might even get to feeling patronizingly fond of him as sort of a mascot.  But surely you can’t build a whole team with a bunch of misfits.  Surely you don’t want to intentionally plant mustard seeds.  After all, the kingdom of God could threaten the borders and boundaries of the kingdoms of this world.   We’ll tolerate a bit of diversity —as long as the old guard remains in a clear majority.  But what if those other folks flourish here and outnumber us?   Surely no one actually plants mustard seeds, right?

Maybe they do.  In God’s kingdom.  Which shelters some and annoys the heck out of others.

Isn’t that what you’ve secretly feared about participating in or—for heaven’s sake—becoming a member of Open Table?  You came here first out of pure curiosity.  Then you started showing up once a month or so, a habit that seemed harmless enough.  You might have helped us host Family Promise one night and saw a little more about God’s kingdom there.  Before you knew what was happening, you started caring, deeply, about the beautifully varied people who are part of this little piece of God’s realm and about what they were doing.  Now you’re serving on the church council, a puzzlement to your friends and to you, too.  And although there’s something salubrious and sheltering about these churchy experiences, there’s also something subversive and invasive and unsettling.  As if the inner landscape of your life is getting rearranged.  As if some kind of spiritual kudzu is growing greenly in your life and reaching out its branching arms into the world around you.  The kingdom of God is like that.

With that creepy and comforting image of how God works in the world, let’s meditate on two aspects of Christian spirituality:
1)     Let us first consider our chosenness within God’s realm
2)     Let us next consider the wildness of God’s realm.

So try to recall a time when you were chosen to contribute lovingly somehow, somewhere.  Maybe someone saw in you something you had not yet seen in yourself.  Maybe someone noticed a quality within you that made you feel a bit more responsible for using that gift for good.  Maybe someone trusted you with a task that you executed well, or that you failed at but you learned from in the process.  Maybe someone chose you as friend.  Something as simple as that.  Think about that one specific occasion of chosenness.  Now ask yourself:  Where was God in that experience?   Did you perhaps experience God’s love in the relationship that developed or through the selflessness evoked in you when you allowed yourself to be used for love’s sake? 

Take a moment to give thanks for that particular occasion when you were chosen for good.  I know there are many such moments, but choose now one moment of chosenness.  Recall it with gratefulness.  Give thanks for being chosen for Love’s purposes.
. . .
Think next about what new opportunity is presenting itself to you.  Are your gifts, experiences, insights, and time being summoned to use here in our faith community?  You may not feel equipped for the job but are nevertheless feeling chosen for it.  You may feel you’re at an age when you don’t have much left to give any more, yet God chooses you again and again because the realm of God still has need of you.  Or you may feel you are too young to be used by God.  But children have special gifts God uses.  Remember the smallest is sometimes the very one God chooses.  Children and adults alike need time to consider what God might be preparing us to do in this world.  This is a question we should regularly take time to consider.  There may be a prophet Samuel coming to you with oil to tap you for lead out in some way.   And remember that in God’s realm, a movement of many can get started from a tiny seed.
 . . .

Let's also admit that sometimes it feels as if we've been chosen for a task that is unfair, that is too hard.  Although we may believe the Spirit of Love would never "choose" to bring suffering, it may still feel, at times, as if God has selected some people for tragedy or hardship.  We may never understand why pain or heartache enters our world, but we can continue to live in ways that trust that God's choice is always love.

So let us meditate now on God’s lovingly invasive spirit that can take root in our lives and spill out into the world.  If God’s greening love is rooted within you, where might others start seeing evidence of it in the world?  Picture sprouts of green leafing out in particular places in your life.  Where is that happening?   If God’s greening and growing love has taken root here in this community of faith, where are other places in our city the offshoots of that love are in evidence?  Picture your influence as mustard plants in and around our city.  Where would you like to see them start cropping up?  Where specifically can you extend God’s love and care, God’s shelter and healing?  Picture one of these specific places.
 . . .
And listen.  Your name is being chosen:  Susan.  George.  David.  Linda.  Chloe.  Bart.    You have been chosen:  Jerry. Ann.  Karen.  The kingdom of God is within you and within those like you: Peter.  Ryan.  Mattie.  God’s work begins like a seed planted in your imagination.  Listen,  Open Table.  You are the mustard seed of churches.  Small.  Seemingly insignificant.  Maybe a bit annoying to some folks.  But something is taking root here.  A new church has been planted.  God only knows what might develop!

Sunday, June 10, 2012

First and Last Sermon On Sin

Text: Genesis 2:15-3:21



              Bart, Jenni, and I returned last night from the annual meeting of the Southeast Conference of the United Church of Christ.  We will share later some of the highlights from the workshops and worship services.  But for sermonic purposes, I’m going to quibble about one tiny typographical error in a worship bulletin that caught my eye on Friday.  One prayer of confession included a phrase that was meant to read “forgiveness of sins.”  Instead, it read “forgiveness of sims.”  Since Sims is my last name, I felt a little singled out.  For a nanosecond it felt as if everyone at the meeting was praying for or about me, that I—though perhaps there was another Sims or two present—needed to be forgiven.  How gracious of them.  How embarrassing for me.
               Although I'm being facetious, the word sin can have powerful associations. Sin is a word we rarely use at Open Table. Not that we are sinless here.  Not that we deny the existence of sin, if we were ever to employ that antique term rather than words like wrongdoing or injurious behavior or immorality or injustice.  But sin is a word to speak sparingly and warily since it is usually wielded in ways that do more harm than good. Even people who wish the best for another can do unintended harm when they use the word sin, and that word creates terrible injury when used to scapegoat, judge, vilify, or dispirit someone.
               But the lection from Genesis today, a story often used to explain how sin entered the world, gives us a chance to consider that word in ways consistent with a healing theology.  Although sin was the subject of every sermon I heard as a child, and “forgive our many sins” was included in the prayers I heard and said growing up, this is the first sermon I’ve preached on the topic, and it may be the last.  So listen up!  You may have only one chance to hear me preach on sin.
               Ironically, I’m jumping into the topic of sin from the diving board of a biblical story that is not really about sin. Contrary to what you’ve been told, sin is NOT the subject of the Adam and Eve myth and the word sin is not to be found there.  When we read Genesis 2 through 3 afresh, without the layers added by St. Paul or St. Augustine or John Milton, for instance—when we try to hear the story divorced from the impressions that high art and popular cultural have left—we recognize that a whole history of interpretation and extrapolation has skewed our understanding of this myth.  For instance, we’ve been told this story teaches that woman was created in a way that subordinates her to man.  We’ve been told this story instituted marriage and explicitly authorized marriage only between a man and a woman, not between Adam and “Steve.” We’ve been told that the serpent was the devil in disguise who tempted the humans to disobey God.  We’ve been told that the fruit of the forbidden tree was specifically an apple, that Adam and Eve’s shame for their nakedness connects the first sin to sex, and that God cursed the first humans for sinning before expelling them from paradise.  These details are simply not in the story as we’ve received it from Genesis.   
               In fact, many scholars instead see within this story an affirmation of the equality of woman who was created, like the male, in God’s image and as partner for the male. They deny Eve is depicted as a sexual temptress and suggest woman is instead presented in the story as the pinnacle of creation since Eve was created last in the list of created beings.  Many insist that while the story is a strong affirmation of the universal need for connection and communion, there’s nothing in this story about marriage; furthermore, only extremely dysfunctional families can be found in the remaining chapters of Genesis, and none of those families could serve as a model for “family values.”  Many believe the talking serpent is a mythical creature with no correlation to the Satan figure and certainly there was not yet a concept of a devil-ruled hell that served as the destination for sinners. Finally, many believe this myth tells us how we grow into human maturity as we test boundaries and exercise curiosity, independence, and self-determination.  Therefore, the story of “man’s fall from grace” is really the story of humanity’s rise from brutish ignorance or childish naiveté into an adult perspective on the world. Genesis 3 does say God cursed the serpent, but God does not curse Eve and Adam.  Rather, God sends them forth to work by the sweat of their brow and bear children through great labor--which seems the price one pays for adult responsibility. One could argue that sin occurs when those capable of doing so do not move into adulthood. As Saint Gregory of Nyssa, a 4th Century Eastern father of the church, said, sin is “the refusal to keep growing.”
               Many note the Eve and Adam story is bookended between Genesis 2: 15 (which says the human was created to till the fields) and Genesis 3:24 (which says the human pair is sent out of the garden to till the ground).  Thus, the myth also stresses that humanity’s adult vocation is caring for the earth.  
               Many argue the doctrine of Original Sin is harmful and unbiblical and should be replaced by the more “original” and biblical concept of Original Blessing, heard repeatedly in Genesis 1 as God approves each created thing as “good.”  What a difference that shift in perspective can make for the ways we love ourselves, one another, our planet, and our God.
               You and I can use this artfully told tale most responsibly if we read it on its own terms, appreciating the richness of its meanings.  Let us at least consider that this story may not tell us how sin entered the world but rather how humans grow into a maturity and into an awareness of their mortality—with all the attendant risks and potential consequences.
               Of course, even if Eve and Adam don’t teach us about sin, that doesn’t mean the Bible is silent on the subject.  It’s just that what gets translated as sin or transgression or iniquity or evil is really a variety of ideas that include ancient purity codes and morals specific to certain cultures plus concerns about social/economic/political injustices .  The psalmist lamented his individual sins. The Hebrew prophets exposed the sins of entire nations that built their empires on the backs of the poor.  Jesus consorted with sinners and forgave sins profligately in ways that angered religious authorities.  The Bible even explicitly defines sins at times, as when St. Paul says that “Anyone, then, who knows the good he ought to do and doesn't do it, sins.”[i]  Sin, many would argue, is “the Bible’s central plot.”[ii]
                So we want to be aware of the various meanings of sin in the Bible and in Christian theology. Since this word remains in the Christian lexicon, progressive Christians probably need to decide if we can retain the word for our theological and liturgical purposes, or if we need to cede its use to others and employ for our theological  conversations some other word or words. 
               Probably the most common understanding of sin locates it in the body, but sin is not mainly a sexual or bodily transgression, contrary to popular culture. As Frederick Buechner says, “Sex is sinful to the degree that, instead of drawing you closer to other human beings in their humanness, it unites bodies but leaves the lives inside them hungrier and more alone than before.”[iii]  Sin is doing what harms ourselves and others.
               Sin is not even entirely a personal act or attitude. Sin exists on an individual level but also on a systemic level.  Sin is both a discrete action and also ingrained patterns or systems of thought and action.  When any human system (economic, religious, educational, political, familial) is oppressive, then that institution, group, nation, or family is a complexly organized force of sin.  Sin operates in structures and implicit cultural codes that demean, harm, or subjugate those God made equal, free, and loved.  Racism, for instance, is a systemic sin.  Both societies and individuals can share complicity for sinful systems.  When we forget these broader meanings of sin, we find it easier to use morality codes to turn certain groups of people into scapegoats and to distract ourselves from our own role in sin’s harm.
               The consequence of sin is death, St. Paul said.  The consequence of eating the fruit of the tree of knowledge is death, the Genesis story imagines God saying to the humans.  But what kind of death?  Eve and Adam do not drop dead after eating the fruit as God’s prediction might have implied.  Initially the serpent seems right and God wrong about that. But death entered their realm of consciousness.  The human pair came to understand their mortality.  Unlike all of the other creatures, humanity had evolved to realize their days are numbered. 
               The natural consequence of sin is death.  Systemic sin is right now poisoning our waters and heating up our planet and exterminating species that the Creator called “good.”  The consequence of sin is death.  But I don’t believe in a death-dealing God who exacts our lives or punishes us into eternity because early literary characters disobeyed a quirky rule. Rather, this story tells me the natural consequence of neglecting or poisoning the garden we were created to tend is that the garden will die.  
               Systemic sin is also widening the gap between the uber-rich and everyone else. Systemic sin is telling female children in many cultures that they are less valued than male children, though the Creator has called them good.  Systemic sin is inciting war among people created to live as the human family, all of whom God called good. The natural consequence of refusing the role of caring partnership with one another is death.
               The consequence of sin in our own private souls is also a kind of death.  We don’t live as fully mature and authentic human beings.  We let parts of ourselves shrivel into nonexistence through neglect.  We kill off pieces of our history and personality and physicality with lack of self-love and self-care and honest self-awareness. 
               One particular consequence of the misuse of the sin story is that we sometimes hang on to the guilt rather than moving ahead into transformation.  Sometimes we accept guilt for things for which the culture condemns but God’s spirit within does not.  Sometimes we’re happy to lie to ourselves and pretend that our actions are not harmful to ourselves or others or that we’re not really responsible. Sometimes we do realize and deeply regret our mistakes but get mired in the guilt and never move forward into God’s grace and forgiveness. 
               I think one reason we can’t shake the guilt is that we find it easier to keep berating ourselves rather than doing the hard work of change.  We accept guilt and all the hurt it causes because it’s our unconscious bargain to punish ourselves with endless self-accusations rather than ask for forgiveness for a past mistake or change the path we’re on now or take a good hard look at our lives. 
               I suggest the church has at least 5 roles in the cycle of sin and forgiveness:
  1. The church gives us gracious and compassionate space and time to contemplate our inner lives and our outer actions.
  2. The church gives us a community that helps us discern what are the good and healthy and life-giving choices and supports us in growing into our best selves and creating our best communities. 
  3. The church gives us language and liturgy to lead us into spiritual health and wholeness.
  4. The church gives us interpretable stories from the past that illuminate our own human predicament in terms of the larger human story.  These sacred stories offer varied metaphors for the central human dilemma. Sin is not the only word for the human predicament.  The Bible also speaks of unawareness, estrangement, exile, blindness, disease, lostness, etc.  Therefore, the way out of our predicament can be expressed and imagined differently, thanks to scripture’s varied pictures of our paths to spiritual growth.[iv] 
  5. The church teaches Jesus’s hopeful way of love.  Love lures us home to God and makes us at home in the world; love reconnects us to those from whom we’ve been estranged; love forgives; love breaks our hearts to see the harm we cause or condone and therefore leads us to repent (which means to change our whole mindset).  Jesus’ commandment to love God, neighbor and self is the simple yet complete antidote to sin.
               Marcus Borg said a Buddhist friend once observed, “You Christians must be very bad people—you’re always confessing your sins."[v]  Yeh. I think there are ways we can regularly and honestly examine our individual lives and our systems—without wallowing in guilt.  My hunch is that the word sin sends us too quickly into a position of self-defense or shame or simply causes us to shut down emotionally and spiritually.  I am looking for words that are better than sin. But I’m interested in your thoughts.  I’m interested in ways we can continue to forge together a language that facilitates our growth and healing.  Amen


[i] James 4:17
[ii] Frederick Buechner, “The Good Book as a Good Book” in The Clown in the Belfry (San Francisco: HarperSanFrancisco, 1992) p. 44.
[iii] Frederick Buechner, “Sin” in Wishful Thinking: A Seeker’s ABC (San Francisco: HarperSanFrancisco, 1993) p. 109.
[iv] See Marcus Borg, “Sin and Salvation” in The Heart of Christianity (San Francisco: HarperSanFrancisco, 2003) pp. 167-171 especially.
[v] Borg, p. 165.
See also Walter Brueggemann, Genesis.  Interpretation: A Bible Commentary for Teaching and Preaching (Atlanta: John Knox, 1982) pp. 40-54 and  Alice Ogden Bellis, "The Story of Eve" in Helpmates, Harlots, and Heroes: Women's Stories in the Hebrew Bible (Louisville: Westminster/John Knox Press, 1994) pp. 45-67.